4 ms·
>>Why should everyone be in the same position? They didn't put in the same effort. For a simple reason - because we know, empirically, through decades of studi
by gambiting 5y ago
>>Why should everyone be in the same position? They didn't put in the same effort.
For a simple reason - because we know, empirically, through decades of studies(some of which were done by the very US of A!), that it produces better results for the entire society. I've learnt long ago that it doesn't matter how I feel about benefits system personally - yeah I hate that some people get money for doing nothing. But it's literally irrelevant - we know through hard data that it works and produces good results. So the whole question of "how much effort has someone put in" is amusing to debate online, but it should be worth exactly zero when deciding policy.
>>The freedom to excel comes with the freedom to do poorly at the game.
Is it freedom though? How many of Americans can't get into these best education programs because they can't afford it? Yes, I am aware that there are grants and funds available if you really are poor - but you still have to apply. What if the chances were really equal - all higher education completely free to attend like it is in some other countries? Both the best university in the country and the worst both have the exact same cost of admission = zero. Isn't that what freedom is?
- quotemstr 5y ago> For a simple reason - because we know, empirically, through decades of studies(some of which were done by the very US of A!), that it produces better results for the entire society Is that why America's per capita GDP is higher than that of the EU? Why the US, not the EU, is the world's center of innovation and the strongest magnet for talent? I don't think that trying to make everyone the same is good for society or conducive to high levels of human accomplishment. Striving for excellence will inevitably produce winners and losers, but if you don't do it, you just end up with mediocrity stew. I'm not going to cut off the right side of the distribution of human accomplishment on the say-so of people who have some weird ideological commitment to human sameness.
- gambiting 5y ago>>Is that why America's per capita GDP is higher than that of the EU? No, but it's exactly why US is far behind EU in healthcare, education, equality, social mobility and a number of other social metrics that matter to you know - normal people on the street, not traders on wall street. GDP doesn't tell the whole story. >>Why the US, not the EU, is the world's center of innovation and the strongest magnet for talent Because US is home to companies that pay ridiculous salaries which make it worth moving to the US for, despite all the other downsides. You're going to get just as good education at many world class universities around the world, but if your goal is extreme salary then US education system gives you a leg up at the start - that's why. Not because there's anything unique or super special about US. >>I don't think that trying to make everyone the same is good for society or conducive to high levels of human accomplishment. That's absolutely not the idea, I think you misunderstood me. The point is to give everyone the same chances. In many other countries it doesn't matter if you're from a rich family or a poor one - it doesn't give you any extra leverage when applying to universities. There is no educational debt to deal with. A medical condition will not put you in any debt whatsoever. Look at it as a gift to the society, to every child and every adult in the country - if they do nothing with it, that is their choice. But if they take these opportunities they can achieve incredible things, exactly that pinnacle of human accomplishment that you're talking about. That's freedom, not the American freedom that's tied to worship of money.
- quotemstr 5y agoIn America, everyone has the same chance already, at least to a close approximation. It's just not logically valid to look at unequal outcomes and conclude that not everyone had the same chance, but that's what half this thread is doing. Whatever the US is doing, it works for producing prosperity and innovation. Whatever the EU is doing doesn't work to produce that. Sure, people there are comfortable, but should comfort alone be the goal of human society? I don't think so.
- Aken 5y ago>> Whatever the US is doing, it works for producing prosperity and innovation. For some, at the expense of others.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoThat is simply not true. One person's success does not take away opportunity from others.
- gambiting 5y agoNo one is attacking personal success here - it's important and should be celebrated. But the opportunities in the US are absolutely not equal, far from it.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoAny person in the US can improve their lot in life. Nobody said it is easy. Success is hard work with a measure of luck. But, it is absolutely possible to go from living on the streets to living in a mansion in a lifetime. How is that not equal opportunity?
- gambiting 5y agoI cannot stop myself but flip this around - how can you possibly call this an equal opportunity? It's like having a race where some people start 100m behind others and saying "well if they try hard enough, they can still win! The race itself is fair after all!" >>Success is hard work with a measure of luck. Of course ,but the American system is 1) ignoring that some people started at a much worse position in life and expecting them to "just work harder" 2) assuming that any problem you might encounter in your life is of your own doing, after all if you get into an accident and end up in lifetime medical debt.....well you shouldn't have gotten into an accident, right? Or again - just work hard to pay it back and you're fine? After all it is possible. Yes, and winning lottery is technically possible but I don't think buying Lotto tickets is a valid way of living your life either.
- notyourday 5y ago> For a simple reason - because we know, empirically, through decades of studies(some of which were done by the very US of A!), that it produces better results for the entire society. It does not - one simply needs to look at USSR, Cuba, Venezuela, North Korea, GDR or any other countries that followed that model.
- gambiting 5y agoI think we might be misunderstanding which "the model" we're talking about. I'm not talking about communism - I come from a former communist country, I know it doesn't work! - I'm talking about modern country with a functional and very comprehensive benefits system with healthcare and education provided to any willing citizen. That's not communism - just capitalism with a comprehensive social support system.
- shoemakersteve 5y agoAh yes, because social security is literally Stalinism.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoI was pretty poor. My mom worked part-time and call centers and did medical studies to earn extra money while my dad worked full-time. I made some bad choices, but then got a 2-year degree at a community college and yes, I did use some grants which I'm very thankful for. Not to be pedantic but there's really no such thing as free is there? Someone is paying for that college. Personally I don't want to subsidize these quote unquote elite universities but if people choose to use their money to go there that's great. To your final point, no that is emphatically not what freedom is. I once heard that freedom is the ability to choose wrongly but at the core it's really freedom to choose. If everything is the same then there's really no choice.
- gambiting 5y ago>>Not to be pedantic but there's really no such thing as free is there? Someone is paying for that college. That is pedantic - literally no one with an ounce of intelligence would think that money for those services comes from the moon. Of course it comes from out taxes. I'm happy to pay my taxes to make sure everyone has the same opportunities. >>Personally I don't want to subsidize these quote unquote elite universities but if people choose to use their money to go there that's great. That's an incredibly individualistic approach that I don't agree with. >>I once heard that freedom is the ability to choose wrongly but at the core it's really freedom to choose. If everything is the same then there's really no choice. But that's exactly what other countries do! I said this in another comment - want to be a doctor? Go ahead, no debt. Want to be a lawyer? No debt. But also want to be a map historian? No debt. Art PhD? No debt. Marketing and Business studies? No debt. That's exactly what freedom is. You are free to chose what you want to learn. If you choose poorly and there is no job waiting for you on the other end, well you just wasted 3 years of your life. But we as a society made it possible for you to take that leap and have a choice. How is that "everything is the same"???
- snowflake_ptr 5y ago>>>Personally I don't want to subsidize these quote unquote elite universities but if people choose to use their money to go there that's great. > That's an incredibly individualistic approach that I don't agree with. You do realize that there are other reasons that people don't want to subsidize universities than just believing that people shouldn't get free education on principle? One really good one is that modern universities are incredibly wasteful. K-12 education has almost tripled in cost over the past 50 years, with virtually no improvement in student reading scores over the same period. College has increased by far more than that. I'm personally happy to pay for other peoples' school with my tax dollars as long as that education is reasonably priced - and so would tens of millions of other Americans. Consider trying to fix the rampant cost metasizing in the education and healthcare systems before trying to subsidize them. Slate Star Codex has a really good article on skyrocketing costs in various sectors: https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost-disease/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost... A second really good reason is that many elite universities are actively pushing murderous ideologies on their students. Marxism literally led to the Chinese Cultural Revolution, which killed tens of millions of people, and these universities are actively cultivating it in their students. I don't know how to describe this except for "evil". These institutions don't just not deserve my money - I want them disbanded, and their leaders' citizenship stripped, for trying to incite violence on a massive scale.
- knicholes 5y agoHow about free online programs like Stanford and MIT Open courseware? Or public libraries? The education is waiting there to be had even without a college tuition or degree.
- gambiting 5y agoWhat about them? I'm not denying there is free education out there. My point is in other countries you have freedom to chose and don't incur debt for your choices. Want to be an IT professional with a 4 year collage degree? No debt. Want to be a doctor with 8 years of education? No debt. Want to be a stylist? No debt. Study ancient history? No debt. Yes, there is free education available in the US - but it's what other people have decided is "worth it", not what you want. That's where I see freedom.
- mentat 5y agoYou have to pass difficult standardized tests to qualify for these spots though. It's not like 50,000 people can just decide they want to be doctors. It depends on ability as measured by testing ability which generally still relates to economic ability in aggregate.