3 ms·
You have to keep in mind that, legally speaking, consideration doesn't have to be monetary. Just because no money changed hands in her contract with Independent
by skissane 5y ago
You have to keep in mind that, legally speaking, consideration doesn't have to be monetary. Just because no money changed hands in her contract with IndependentSoftwareFoundation doesn't mean there was no consideration involved.
- CRConrad 5y agoBut there is no a priori assumption that there was any consideration, whereas with the employment contract there is quite obviously, as standard, quite significant remuneration. So, sorry, but I think anyone will have a hard time arguing against "How could you think you had that left to give away to Party X, when you already took / are taking the money for selling it to Party Y?"
- skissane 5y agoIn common law systems, if there is a contract there is consideration. Without consideration (which doesn't necessarily have to be monetary), there cannot be a contract (although you could have some other form of legal agreement, such as a deed or promissory estoppel.) So, when I presented a hypothetical involving two contradictory contracts, both contracts (presuming a common law legal system) necessarily have consideration, or else you are denying one of the premises of the hypothetical.
- CRConrad 5y agoSo what kind of contract for consideration did Alice sign with a free software project? Your hypothetical feels very hypothetical.
- skissane 5y agoIt isn't hypothetical at all. The FSF's standard copyright assignment contract includes consideration on both sides – the contributor's consideration is assignment of copyright, the FSF's consideration is a non-exclusive license to said copyright. It has to include consideration on both sides or else it wouldn't be a legally valid contract. (You can still have a legal agreement without any consideration, but then it has to be a deed not a contract; people often prefer contracts to deeds because in many jurisdictions deeds have more stringent formality requirements.) Another possible consideration the project could offer Alice would be the intangible benefit of having her code included in the project. Those intangible benefits include the benefits to Alice's reputation (she can truthfully say "I wrote part of X"), and also the maintenance benefits of upstreaming code. Legally, consideration doesn't have to monetary. It can be something intangible, such as a copyright license, reputational benefits, the maintenance benefits of upstreaming, etc. All that's really necessary for consideration to exist is each side has to give something to the other, but usually the legal standards for what counts as consideration are pretty low.
- CRConrad 5y agoA) rather weird definition of "consideration". One would have thought this means something that can be accepted in lieu of what is given up, i.e. can at least somehow plausibly be claimed to be of equivalent value. But "a non-exclusive license to said copyright" is a strict sub-set of said copyright, so it can only ever be worth less. That's as much "consideration" as, say, "from now on you'll work for me sixteen hours out of every twenty-four. As consideration, I'll let you have the other eight off." Uh, I owned all of my time so far, and now you come out of the blue and want to make me your slave. How is you not suddenly taking a small part of my life "consideration" for taking most of it? B)ut still: If she does that while already being employed, then she has already signed away those rights to her employer (in [most jurisdictions of] the USA). So she just simply no longer possesses those rights to sign away to any project, whether for consideration or not. Because as an employee, she almost certainly already got consideration (salary) for them. The monthly (or is it still weekly / biweekly over there?) paycheck is just such a humongously obvious proof and reminder of this.