7 ms·
I find myself wondering whether Google’s front end implements a fully generic tracker: collect source address and headers and forward it to an analytics system.
by amluto 5y ago
I find myself wondering whether Google’s front end implements a fully generic tracker: collect source address and headers and forward it to an analytics system. The developers involved in each individual Google property behind the front end might not even know it’s there. Correlating the headers with the set of URLs hit and their timing might give quite a lot of information about the pages being visited.
I hope Google doesn’t do this, but I would not be entirely surprised if they did.
- fogihujy 5y agoUnless it's regularly verified by a trusted third party, such as a government agency, I wouldn't trust them not to. After all: we're talking about a corporation that lives off the data it gathers about people using their services and products.
- londons_explore 5y agoIf the frontend had a fully generic tracker, teams wouldn't need to set up their own logging and stats systems... Which they do...
- lars 5y agoI think they would in any case. My impression is that data is siloed internally at Google, and that data sharing between departments would be way more complex than just setting up some (possibly redundant) logging.
- Filligree 5y agoI spent ten seconds thinking about the logistics of adding logging to the frontends, and... Well, obviously I can't say for sure they don't have any. I didn't look it up, and if I had I wouldn't be able to tell you. But since I didn't, I can tell you that the concept seems completely infeasible. There's too much traffic, and nowhere to put them. Besides that, not everything is legal to log. The frontends don't know what they're seeing, though; they're generic reverse proxies. So...
- nacs 5y ago> completely infeasible. There's too much traffic, and nowhere to put them If there’s one company in the world for whom bandwidth and storage are not an issue, it’s Google.
- phh 5y agoIt sounds so easy to make, yet so useful, that I can't see how they wouldn't do that. Deontology has been thrown out Google's window a long time ago.