4 ms·
Suppose Alice has signed two contracts, one with her employer assigning them copyright in whatever she develops, and another with IndependentSoftwareFoundation
by skissane 5y ago
Suppose Alice has signed two contracts, one with her employer assigning them copyright in whatever she develops, and another with IndependentSoftwareFoundation assigning them copyright in something particular she develops. Why automatically assume the former contract legally trumps the later?
Also, employees can act as agents for their employers. Suppose Alice falsely warrants to IndependentSoftwareFoundation that she has her employer's approval to submit the code in question. If an employee makes an unauthorised agreement with IndependentSoftwareFoundation, I don't think a court will necessarily automatically invalidate that agreement just because the employee wasn't properly authorised. It depends on the circumstances.
It is like the case of the employee who buys an expensive dinner on the corporate credit card, and then the employer rejects the expense claim as violating policy. The employer can't refuse to pay the credit card company, or the restaurant, because the employee violated policy. The most the employer can do is fire the employee and sue them for damages. The employee entered into a contract with the restaurant on behalf of their employer, and the employer is bound by the contract even if the employee wasn't authorised to enter into it.
> In the same way I can't legally sell you a copy of Windows license that I totally promise I've got an agreement with MS about. It's not a license I have rights to.
Different situation in a couple of ways. Firstly, you didn't have anything to do with developing Windows. Suppose a Windows developer writes some code and puts it in Windows (under their Microsoft employee copyright assignment) then puts the same code in some open source project (under some other copyright assignment they sign without Microsoft's knowledge or consent). That's the scenario I'm talking about here which is rather different from the scenario you are talking about.
Secondly, Microsoft Windows is famous and if some random person (with no apparent association with Microsoft) tries to sell you a license to it you have good reason to suspect the license is invalid. Some random piece of code a developer writes isn't famous and so someone who receives it doesn't have the same grounds for suspecting it. Courts tend to have more sympathy for people who make reasonable good faith assumptions than for people who assume things that a reasonable person should know are unlikely to be true.
As I said, I'm not a lawyer and I'm not claiming any particular answer here is necessarily the right one. I think it likely depends on the jurisdiction and the specific details of each particular case. I just don't think it is as clearcut as some other people (including yourself) seem to think it is.
- viraptor 5y agoWhat the court decides with regards to damages and similar issues is a bit fuzzy of course. But the original claim was "That way they are absolutely sure that there will never be a problem." - and for that one, it's obviously not true - it's going to be a problem in the situation I described. It may be a mistake with a good faith assumption, and there may be agreements because it's a trivial amount of code. But it's not going to be "haha, that person did a little bit of fraud, let's ignore it".
- skissane 5y ago> What the court decides with regards to damages and similar issues is a bit fuzzy of course. It isn't just fuzzy what the court will decide with regards to damages – I think it is also (at least sometimes) going to be fuzzy with respect to what the court will decide as to the substance of the dispute. > But the original claim was "That way they are absolutely sure that there will never be a problem." - and for that one, it's obviously not true You can never be absolutely sure there isn't going to be a problem. But you can't be sure there is going to be one either. > But it's not going to be "haha, that person did a little bit of fraud, let's ignore it". There isn't necessarily any fraud involved here. The employee may have a good faith (even if mistaken) belief that they are allowed to submit the code to the open source project. The open source project may have a good faith and reasonable belief that they are legally allowed to receive it. In that scenario, neither party is committing any fraud. And if the employer later decides they don't agree with what happened, there is no guarantee the employer will necessarily always win a case against the open source project.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Suppose Alice has signed two contracts, one with her employer assigning them copyright in whatever she develops, and another with IndependentSoftwareFoundation assigning them copyright in something particular she develops. Why automatically assume the former contract legally trumps the later? The legal system probably will (and I gotta admit it seems reasonable to me too), because she received consideration for the former contract.
- 5y ago