3 ms·
> The original author contributes the code under "or any later version". That’s the part I’m stuck on. How would I do that on code I do not own, because I wrot
by kube-system 5y ago
> The original author contributes the code under "or any later version".
That’s the part I’m stuck on. How would I do that on code I do not own, because I wrote it for hire?
I’m guessing there a legal answer to this question somehow, it has to have come up at some point.
- rswail 5y agoYou don't own the copyright so you can't license it under any licenses. So your original contribution was unlicensed and therefore the owner of the copyright can declare all use by anyone as infringement on their IPRs.
- lmm 5y ago> That’s the part I’m stuck on. How would I do that on code I do not own, because I wrote it for hire? Well anyone can write a letter that says "I hereby grant you a license to use this code under these terms...", but if they don't hold the copyright on it then the letter is meaningless (or maybe fraudulent). So in court you would have to prove that that person's copyright is actually valid, and if the code was written by someone who was employed and their employer didn't sign a disclaimer of work-for-hire ownership claims, then that could be disputed. If you want to enforce the copyright against other people, as the FSF did, then that's bad. If you just want to avoid getting sued yourself, then it's probably not really a problem, because the employer would have to positively prove that they held the copyright to be able to enforce it. That said, some projects that don't require copyright assignment do still require a disclaimer of work-for-hire claims in their CLA.