3 ms·
There are libertarians and anarchists who think that freedom is having no laws at all. But what happens when a huge chemical company starts dumping waste on you
by globular-toast 5y ago
There are libertarians and anarchists who think that freedom is having no laws at all. But what happens when a huge chemical company starts dumping waste on your lawn? Who do you call? They are free to do what they want, aren't they?
Individual liberties can only go so far. If we want freedom as a society it is necessary to restrict individual freedom at the point that it begins to affect the freedoms and rights of others. In practice that means, unfortunately, governments, police and armies are necessary.
Permissive licences are idealistic. Copyleft/FSF-style licences are pragmatic.
- superjan 5y agoI think your point is that copyleft creates extra value because those extending it are incentivized to contribute their extensions. But in the case of gcc as compared to llvm, permissive licensing looks to be at least as successful. An issue with copyleft that you need to commit to providing the source beforehand. If you are allowed to choose afterwards, you don’t need to ask in advance, and it’s easier to make the case that upstreaming your patches is in the organization’s best interest. And yes I know copyleft only requires only providing code to your users, but in practice the organization assumes that means the distribution can’t be enforced.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoLibertarians still believe in property rights and a sufficient legal system that the answer to > But what happens when a huge chemical company starts dumping waste on your lawn? is "sue them to oblivion".
- CRConrad 5y agoBut when they start dumping it on the common meadow behind your property, or the street in front of it, you can't do shit because you don't own those... And libertarians only believe in a legal system sufficient to protect property rights and nothing else. They should call themselves selfitarians, because what they're all about isn't "liberty", but selfishness.