3 ms·
I think the issue is that we've actually moved away from targeted ads somehow. These ads aren't targeted ads, they are a best guess what you might want to buy.
by asdff 5y ago
I think the issue is that we've actually moved away from targeted ads somehow. These ads aren't targeted ads, they are a best guess what you might want to buy. A targeted ad to me is something like an ad for some niche interest piece of gear on a website or magazine for that specific niche interest. 100% of your ad dollars in this case go to throwing an ad in front of what is guarenteed to be your customer base. When pampers tries to sell me diapers because I am of that age where people tend to have kids, that falls flat because they only guess that I am their customer base, rather than targeting that base explicitly like banner advertisement on a new parents forum.
- zerocrates 5y agoYeah I mean this is the thing. The ad market is dominated by the players who have a bunch of info about users/visitors and do user-specific targeting with that data. My understanding is that the payment rates for "targeted" ads in the sense of "place them on this site/article because it's a relevant topic" have plummeted. Further, the extreme trackability of actual ad engagement I think has devalued the sense of value in just "your ad in front of eyeballs": I don't know that an ad you don't click on but that causes you to buy through other channels later really gets valued (though with the amount of tracking that happens maybe people are actually capturing this too). The other thing that doesn't necessarily get tracked would be "your ad is so annoying/invasive/battery-draining/spookily-targeted that it actually turns people off from buying": they're just non-converted impressions same as any other. (There's also clearly a large component of "very few people really get turned off by ads, if they noticed you even out of annoyance that's good on balance" which might be true, I don't know.) We'd have seen a shift in ad dollars regardless just owing to how much time people spend online and on mobile devices especially, but how much of the shift is driven just by the availability of the metrics? Again, the metrics are one of these things that's good for both theoretically-opposing "sides" of the ad market: the ad networks can obviously pitch them to marketing, and marketing can in turn use them to justify the ad budget.