7 ms·
"and Apple has deliberately framed the question such that almost no-one will say yes" Translation: Apple worded the question plainly and without deception.
by perihelions 5y ago
"and Apple has deliberately framed the question such that almost no-one will say yes"
Translation: Apple worded the question plainly and without deception.
- nicbou 5y agoI just looked it up, and you're right. It's plain as day, and completely neutral.
- benedictevans 5y agoIn different parts of your iOS settings, Apple will ask you it it's OK for ads to 'track' you, OK to 'personalise' ads and OK to 'measure ad effectiveness'. Framing is important.
- cosmojg 5y agoThose all sound reasonable and unbiased to me. That's exactly what most ads and cookies do.
- hyperpape 5y agoI’m on Apple’s side, and think all three phrasings are fine. However, I think that “track” sounds much more invasive than personalize. Of course we know they’re the same damn thing, but “personalized” sounds more innocent.
- Dah00n 5y agoHow do you "measure ad effectiveness" without tracking the user? Tracking is definitely the worst of the bunch so "measure ad effectiveness" have to be better/less pervasive than allowing tracking if it is unbiased, otherwise it should say "tracking".
- lmkg 5y agoApple (Webkit) has proposed a browser feature that would allow tracking ad click-to-conversion without tracking the user or click. It involves the browser phoning home with low-entropy identifiers. https://webkit.org/blog/11529/introducing-private-click-measurement-pcm/ https://webkit.org/blog/11529/introducing-private-click-meas... From a pure privacy perspective, it's odd because it involves the browser collaborating in measuring the results of your behavior. I think it shares several of the concerns with Google's FLoC and "privacy sandbox" proposals. It only makes sense if you buy into Apple's perspective that there's a level of "acceptable" tracking, and new tracking features under that threshold are acceptable if they give Apple the political capital to kill tracking technology that crosses that threshold. It's a bit much to swallow. But they are at least trying to address that concern.
- Dah00n 5y agoI see, I hadn't heard about that. Thank you :)
- benedictevans 5y agoApple makes you opt into the first, but the second two are turned on by default. Those are Apple’s own services. Framing is important.
- FabHK 5y agoHe was probably expecting the totally neutral and impartial Facebook framing of “help small businesses and help us keep Facebook free”…
- the_snooze 5y agoWhen you get rid of leading questions and dark patterns, it turns out people don't actually want to be tracked! surprisedpikachu.jpg
- madeofpalk 5y agoFor clarity, the question is: > "App Name" would like permission to track you across apps and websites owned by other companies > [Allow Tracking] > [As App Not to Track] And then also the app developer can put in their own small description that shows in addition to the above. This seems incredibly fair and conscience. It is an objective statement of facts that is only biased because the reality is something that most people probably don't like.
- zzyzxd 5y ago> without deception I am not a native English speaker, but I am not sure about that. Look at the word "track" -- pretty much no one would want to be tracked, right? I guess if they replace "track" with "identify", more people would actually allow that. Something like "Allow this app to identify your device across apps and websites". Average users usually don't have problem being identified. They use the same email across websites, and will prefer facebook login on 3rd party websites if it is an option... End of day, the thing getting blocked by the prompt is iOS IDFA, where letters "ID" mean "identifier". But still, I don't mind Apply play a little wording game here. The ad industry, on the other side, did way uglier than Apple in the last decade.
- edoceo 5y agoIDFA? IDentifier For Advertising? I mean if your asking for ID, they Why is always there: to prove age, to track, etc. So, calling it "track" in their (Apple) messaging is good. Its the Identifier to Track You.
- wrboyce 5y agoI am a native speaker, and we are being far more than “identified” by these invasions. Why should Apple be using softer, less accurate, English to protect the likes of Facebook? This is not something to sugar coat, it is something to call out plainly.