3 ms·
I guess that depends on definitions of "pervasive and important" more than it does facts on the ground. To my eyes, the number of open source drivers (near zer
by ajross 5y ago
I guess that depends on definitions of "pervasive and important" more than it does facts on the ground.
To my eyes, the number of open source drivers (near zero) available for Apple hardware, developed to run on their BSD-licensed kernel, pretty much provides all the evidence I need.
No, a BSD Linux would have long since disappeared behind the curtain of some tech giant or another, just like Mach did into NeXT/Apple.
- ghaff 5y agoThough binary blobs are a thing, albeit a somewhat controversial thing. Assuming a BSD-licensed Linux is a fairly small step away from assuming that Linux didn't exist given the existence of various BSD Unix flavors. And most people I know feel fairly strongly that, in the absence of Linux, BSD Unix would have come to the forefront.
- Macha 5y agoBut would it have come to the forefront in the form of FreeBSD, or in the form of macOS or a similar system?
- ghaff 5y agoService providers were already using the BSDs in the dot-com buildup when Linux wasn't quite as far along. For anyone interested, here's a debate between Bryan Cantrill and Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols I recorded last year on the topic "If Linux didn't exist, would we have had to invent it?" https://grhpodcasts.s3.amazonaws.com/Cantrill_Nichols.mp3 https://grhpodcasts.s3.amazonaws.com/Cantrill_Nichols.mp3
- pjmlp 5y agoDuring the dot-com buildup all Portuguese mobile provides were on our customer list, none of them cared about BSD. I was porting software between Windows NT/2000, HP-UX, Solaris and Aix. The Red-Hat Linux and FreeBSD boxes we had on the office were used for sharing mp3s, quake server, and replication of our CVS server.
- ipaddr 5y agoWhy do they feel that way? It is debatable they would have finished, gotten the same press vs one guy who did it and without requiring changes back development might not have been able to keep up.
- ghaff 5y agoLinux largely won out over the BSDs for various reasons that may (or may not) have included the license. I personally think Linux would be roughly where it is even if it used a BSD license. And in the absence of Linux entirely, most people I know consider that one of the BSDs would have been rallied around because there was just too much market demand for an open source *nix operating system.
- pjmlp 5y agoHad the BSD lawsuit not happened, commercial UNIXes would be getting BSD stuff like they did 10 years before it. Also all new POSIX FOSS OS for IoT are MIT/Apache license based, just give them a couple of years and see which one board makers will be picking.