3 ms·
> Ironic that this sentiment is expressed on HN, a centrally controlled site with strict rules around what can and cannot be said. I say this on my own website
by sneak 5y ago
> Ironic that this sentiment is expressed on HN, a centrally controlled site with strict rules around what can and cannot be said.
I say this on my own website, on other sites, and here too - it's not an exclusive thing. This isn't the gotcha you seem to think it is.
> you rail against Instagram's no nudity policy, something that almost all people agree that the site is better off without.
Citation needed. This is your opinion, not fact. There are many thousands of fine art photographers who can't share the majority of their work on IG, and hobbyists who have lost their entire accounts and audience simply because Facebook's censors can't tell a male nipple from a female one. Many people into fetish clothing and jewelry design can't even post non-nude images showcasing their products. There isn't the wide consensus you imagine.
> And yet, have you tried posting nudity on HN? Let us know if it stays up. HN's control over topics that can be discussed is so firm that even potentially interesting threads like...
I actually wrote and operate a little hobby site that exists solely to detect and highlight stories upvoted by HN's readership and marked as off topic (and hidden) by HN's administrators: https://orangesite.sneak.cloud https://orangesite.sneak.cloud
People should be able to decide for themselves what they see and read, including delegating that authority. HN, for example, has the "showdead" preference option for opting in to seeing comments marked dead by the mods.
HN strikes a good balance, and lets people opt in or out of comment moderation. Facebook and Google do not.
- zzo38computer 5y ago> People should be able to decide for themselves what they see and read, including delegating that authority. HN, for example, has the "showdead" preference option for opting in to seeing comments marked dead by the mods. > HN strikes a good balance, and lets people opt in or out of comment moderation. While this is a good idea (and I use the showdead option myself), it is incomplete. To complete it might include such thing as: - Add another preference option to force everything to be displayed in chronological order. - If you have enough disk space to allow it, allow replies to dead and old messages, which are automatically also dead.