3 ms·
> No employee ever genuflected to me You're arguing in bad faith by making a caricature out of my argument. Please don't. I meant there is a clear dependency,
by etripe 5y ago
> No employee ever genuflected to me
You're arguing in bad faith by making a caricature out of my argument. Please don't. I meant there is a clear dependency, like in software. Your app isn't free of dependencies if it imports other packages. It needs them to function. There's vendor lock-in.
> Either party could walk away
This might have been true for you, but doesn't generalise well. Yes, in theory people can walk away. In practice, they're dependent on their employer for healthcare coverage, survival, general life stability... etc.
It's not because you or I currently have a financial buffer and can survive stretches of unemployment that this is the case for the entire population. In case you missed it, a majority of Americans cannot afford a $500 dollar surprise expense out of pocket (0).
Imagine you're a millennial with college debt in an area without a lot of jobs and analyse how free you really are to leave the one job you managed to get. How likely are you to get funding for a business? What's the tensile strength of your bootstraps?
You're entitled to look at it as a simple transaction, but the distribution of leverage for most people is distinctly asymmetrical, especially in anti-union countries like the US. So are the legal advantages, political influence, legal accountability, etc when comparing companies to individuals.
[0] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/most-americans-cant-afford-a-500-emergency-expense/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/most-americans-cant-afford-a-50...
- WalterBright 5y ago> Yes, in theory people can walk away. In practice, they do, all the time, in every place I've ever worked, including min wage jobs. > they're dependent on their employer for healthcare coverage That's because of stupid government laws. Besides, if you leave you get COBRA for 18 months or something like that. > survival, Not in the US. Don't exaggerate. > general life stability... ?? > a majority of Americans cannot afford a $500 dollar surprise expense out of pocket (0). That doesn't mean they're poor. It's easy to have a quarter million dollar salary and spend 110% of it. > in an area without a lot of jobs Hop on the Bus, Gus. Go where the jobs are. My extended family moved all over the US for better jobs. Heck, I wound up in Seattle to get a better job. Cost me a couple hundred clams worth of gas driving my bucket of bolts there from Kansas. Heck, somehow the penniless migrants manage to travel all over the US to get work. > So are the legal advantages, political influence, legal accountability, etc when comparing companies to individuals. The courts are heavily biased in favor of the worker in legal disputes. And have you ever seen the press take the side of Amazon in any dispute with labor? Or any company?