9 ms·
From the G7 agenda reporting: “ Last Friday morning, during an interview on Good Morning America, U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said the
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
From the G7 agenda reporting:
“ Last Friday morning, during an interview on Good Morning America, U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said the Biden administration was taking “a very close look” at the possibility of vaccine passports for travel into and out of the United States.
However by Friday afternoon the Department of Homeland Security was clarifying Mayorkas’ statement. The DHS says there won’t be any federal vaccination database nor any mandate that requires people to get a single vaccination credential. It also said there are no plans for anything like a U.S. passport.”
The U.S. is suspicious of many types of documentation. E.g. none needed for voting in many areas, etc. The culture tends towards erring on less bureaucracy.
If more states ban covid-passports, I wonder if the EU would rather not have tourists than allow visitations.
Once there is a vaccine surplus, the vast amount of risk is on those who decide out of their own volition to not get vaccinated, at which point society can’t hold their hands anymore.
- leipert 5y agoWell a COVID pass would still be useful inside the EU, e.g. I can leave the yellow vaccination pass at home, can show it when coming home from outside of the EU or if I go somewhere where a negative test or vaccination is required.
- m_st 5y agoWe Swiss people are also quite suspicious with this kind of documentation (Google Fichenaffäre / secret files scandal for reasons). To my understanding you will get this Covid certificate either through vaccination, after having had Covid-19 or after a negative test. So it's not like a central vaccine database or so. (Note that we had such a database called "Elektronischer Impfausweis" but it had to be taken down after it was found to be a mess in security)
- zhdc1 5y agoAmericans are far more distrustful. The idea of registering with your local municipality is downright alien in the United States. At best, you're required to eventually update your drivers license when you switch states, which (depending on the state) is the equivalent of "maybe" updating your license and vehicle registration whenever you eventually get around to it. Compare that against moving between, say, Switzerland and Poland (or any other combination of Schengen member countries).
- CaptainZapp 5y agoYou actually get heavily fined when you move to Switzerland and use your foreign license for more than a year. Exchanging it is a small formality in most cases, but you need to do it.
- swiley 5y agoDoesn't that creep you out at least a little bit?
- zhdc1 5y agoIt also - technically - works that way in the US as well when it comes to drivers licenses (although it depends on the state). The difference is that it's actually enforced in Switzerland, and depending on which country you emigrate in from, you can also be forced to retake your drivers test if you wait long enough (which is something of a less-discussed issue in the expat community).
- rsynnott 5y agoI think you have to do this basically everywhere? Exception would be within the EU (and possibly within the US, though I thought there were license compatibility problems there).
- swiley 5y agoI'm in the US and don't keep my driver's license up to date. It's really a minor thing police mention if you get pulled over/into an accident but otherwise doesn't matter.
- dvdkon 5y agoNot really. I think some people associate driving a car with freedom of movement. I get it, when it's your primary mode of transport, it feels dystopian to have it taken away. Interestingly, I get a similar feeling in places with no/unreliable public transport or in countries where I can't walk through forests, meadows and fields. Not that walking through fields is my primary way of traveling, but it feels reassuring to know I can leave by just walking away (and then catching a bus to get home).
- uselessphd 5y agoSwiss software, like Swiss cheese, seems to come with holes.. security holes
- CaptainZapp 5y ago> If more states ban covid-passports, I wonder if the EU would rather not have tourists than allow visitations. That's certainly a possibility if safety really is a concern. But I'd wager that the average American anti Covid fanatic (the sort: Masks are fascism! It's like what the nazis did with the jews!) is not really the kind of person travelling the world. I don't think that others, who want to travel the world really mind getting the necessary documentation. The whole principle that you need to prove vaccination to be let into a country is not really new. And there's the yellow vaccine passport issued by the WHO, which exists for decades. I needed to show proof for a yellow fever vaccination when travelling to Venezuela. And that was in 1989.
- Pyramus 5y ago> The whole principle that you need to prove vaccination to be let into a country is not really new. Exactly. Necessary and recommended vaccinations are one of the first things to check when planning a trip to destinations in Africa, South East Asia etc.
- mirekrusin 5y agoIn many countries they don't accept kids to nursery without up to date vacinnation card.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThey also don’t allow you to collect welfare unless you and your kids have received your vaccinations (Australia).
- hwbehrens 5y agoThis is true in the U.S. as well [0]. Some states allow for religious, philosophical, or medical exemptions; these exceptions are similar to the systems implemented in the Netherlands (religious [1]), Australia (philosophical [2]) or Germany (medical [1]). [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccination_policy_in_the_United_States#School_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaccination_policy_in_the_Unit... [1]: https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1057/s41271-019-00163-8.pdf https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1057/s41271-019-001... [2]: https://www.sabin.org/sites/sabin.org/files/restricted/Salmon_etal_compulsory_imm_06.pdf https://www.sabin.org/sites/sabin.org/files/restricted/Salmo...
- Ciantic 5y agoYou can still get in with a negative test even if no passports are recognized between EU / US. Getting tested maybe annoying for sure, but it's part of the scheme going to Switzerland, and presumably to EU also. I think everything depends how long the covid is issue to the hospitals of the destination country. If the vaccines are very potent, as it looks like from in Israel, then it might be that most of Europe & US can already travel freely without passports at the end of year.
- jollybean 5y agoBritish Colombia is wary of them on the basis of inequity, which is not unreasonable, that said, they may be doing something for international travel. The Swiss thing looks kinda complicated, and likely hard for other countries to participate. Easy Solution: issue a passport insert + seal. Go to the hospital/clinic, show your passport, they give you a seal, a stamp, a number, and a signature. The number can be typed into a computer to match with last name and first initial so border people can check. The insert can be some kind of things that's hard to fake + the stamp would be required. Alternatively - you take a doctor's note down to the DMV and they issue you a little temp/card/id with your name and photo. So there's a 'central standard' but no overarching bureaucracy.
- traspler 5y agoIt‘s basically a PKI and this design was chosen with the explicit goal to participate in the EU Green Pass project with the goal that all EU members can participate in the same system. When the the system stands the only bureaucracy will be for an issuer to get a cert from the authority or for an authority to be included in the root. All the things you describe with the seal and number and system to validate is just as much if not more bureaucracy and is not that far off from the proposed solution.
- jollybean 5y agoThe difference is there's no hard dependency on centralized authority or any kind of complex web or mobile technologies. IT is complicated. Many orgs are still running ridiculous old systems. A lot of people don't have mobiles phones, or generally don't know how to use them properly, may not have data services or even an email address. The 'COVID tracer' app issued by gov. Canada has barely anyone using it. TN visas (NAFTA visas for US/Can/Mexico) are obtained at the border, it's just something stapled into your passport. That's it. And that entitles you to live in a foreign country. We could feasibly do the same with COVID tags. It's really hard to set up government agencies that operate effectively with all the bells and whistles, it's costly, tons of consultants, tons of service calls & support ... by leveraging the DMV or it's equivalent, you already have most of the infrastructure in place: they know how to check and issue IDs, they have processes for appointments, service calls, queuing, putting out support content that meets standards (i.e. disabled, elderly), actual phone numbers and physical people to speak to for those who are used to that. For the same reason bank tellers still exist. We used to do some amazingly complicated things without IT.
- heywherelogingo 5y agoThe UK has also ruled it out. I wouldn't use one - emigrate or never travel. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2021/05/30/uk-vaccine-passport-plans-scrapped/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2021/05/30/uk-vaccine-p...
- pimterry 5y agoThe UK has ruled it out as a solution for large local events and cultural activities, they haven't ruled out vaccine passports in general. As far as I can tell they're still very much planned for inbound international travel to the UK, and they're already in use for outbound international travel - the NHS app is accepted as proof of vaccination status at the border when entering quite a few countries e.g. Greece https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/greece/entry-requirements#demonstrating-your-covid-19-vaccination-status https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/greece/entry-requir...
- chinathrow 5y agoHave you never travelled to a vaccination mandatory country where you needed to prove vaccination against e.g. Yellow fever?
- rsynnott 5y agoI would, er, plan on getting very used to wherever you are now, then. I'd assume most countries will require some sort of documentation on this.
- tpm 5y agoEU internally will use the so-called covid green pass however being vaccinated will not be a condition for travelling: https://ec.europa.eu/info/live-work-travel-eu/coronavirus-response/safe-covid-19-vaccines-europeans/eu-digital-covid-certificate_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/live-work-travel-eu/coronavirus-re... I think the same logic will apply for visits from rest of the world.
- rsynnott 5y ago> If more states ban covid-passports, I wonder if the EU would rather not have tourists than allow visitations. I assume people coming from non-vaccine-passport countries will require additional documentation (ie they'll have to prove vaccination, just not in a standardized way)
- refurb 5y agoI think the cat is out of the bag for the US at this point. My understanding is many (most?) states did not require ID and you could provide any name you wanted. The vaccine cards are easily faked so at this point, what proof so people have they got the vaccine? If you got it at Kaiser or UCSF it’s probably in your records, but beyond that? I’m guessing that people will need to get a vaccine antigen test to prove immunogenicity and then get that officially certified.
- xg15 5y ago> The U.S. is suspicious of many types of documentation. E.g. none needed for voting in many areas, etc. The culture tends towards erring on less bureaucracy. I used to respect that viewpoint - but, honestly, I can't take it seriously anymore after we learned first of NSA mass surveillance and then of the loaded discussion about voter fraud and the byzantine voter registration procedures. The US is still drawing up a specter from the cold war era while ignoring that those danger never materialized when national IDs where actually issued - and while actively developing tech that is far more invasive than a simple ID. I think by now, introducing a federal ID could even help the fight against racism: If there was a single federal ID that was easily obtainable for any US citizen, that would remove the need for all the different and in part discriminatory registration systems, while still allowing voter fraud concerns to be addressed.