3 ms·
Why isn't Lord of the Rings "science fiction" but Star Wars is? They both have technology unknown to us.
by lupire 5y ago
Why isn't Lord of the Rings "science fiction" but Star Wars is? They both have technology unknown to us.
- ben_w 5y agoLotR magic isn’t supposed to be technology, it’s literal-god (Eru Ilúvatar) created everything by singing, literal-devil (Morgoth) has a different and incompatible song, some legendary things happened (only in-universe they actually happened and aren’t mere tales like our myths, and the elves being immortal can remember them), and then the literal spirits of literal minor angels (Maiar) took human form and did magic as the wizards.
- robbrown451 5y agoThings like this can lie on a spectrum. That said, Lord of the Rings has a lot more traditional things like elves and fairies and wizards, and a lot more "pure" magic. They are also completely lacking much of technology from today or even the time it was created... no telephones or automobiles, for instance. (Star Wars has things that are more advanced versions of these)