You are conflating good and popular which leads to a lot of confusion. They aren’t unrelated, but all these positions are false: - something can't be really p

You are conflating good and popular which leads to a lot of confusion. They aren’t unrelated, but all these positions are false: - something can't be really popular and really good - something can't be really good but not popular - something can't be popular but not very good It is, of course, also quite possible to be not good and not popular but this isn't very interesting.