2 ms·
I actually question the premise. The NYRB and LRB are alive and well afaik. I read reviews all the time in the Guardian. At a second tier, honest customer revi
by ggm 5y ago
I actually question the premise. The NYRB and LRB are alive and well afaik. I read reviews all the time in the Guardian.
At a second tier, honest customer reviews exist in kindle. Sometimes they are dreck, but you can apply critical faculties to what people say.
I agree in principle there is "less" than there used to be but there isn't "none" and I think I have bought at least three books recently purely on the strength of in-depth reviews I read online
(they were Ross King: the Bookseller of Florence, Emma Southon: A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum and Geraldine Brooks: Year of Wonders And, the first two which I have read, had merits and issues, and the review highlighted both as I recall)
- karaterobot 5y agoMy takeaway from the article wasn't that there aren't people reviewing books anymore, but that fewer people today can make a living writing informed criticism about style and technique, as opposed to about how a book makes them feel, or how it fits into an ongoing cultural conversation.
- ggm 5y agoYea, maybe because I buy more non fiction i mistake review for literary criticism. I'm probably unaware of the change in eng. Lit. as a field. I always found other peoples take on a lyrical quality in somebody's writing as less useful than "it's a coherent narrative" -I know how Rushdie or Vikram seth write: i want to know how concretely plausible or accurate their story is regarding Indian social affairs of the time.