3 ms·
> I don't buy the idea that literary criticism accomplished anything except act as gate keepers that ensured only the right voices were celebrated. Go back to
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> I don't buy the idea that literary criticism accomplished anything except act as gate keepers that ensured only the right voices were celebrated.
Go back to 1959 then. You had serious literary critics. You also had the New York Times bestseller list. How much overlap was there? I can't be sure, since that was a bit before my time, but I strongly suspect that the answer is "not much". The public didn't pay much attention to the highbrow critics back then, either.
What the highbrow critics did was gatekeep what the highbrow people read. Or perhaps what they admitted to read, or claimed that they read. The general public may have read the highbrow reviews - aspirational high-brow-ism was more of a thing in that day than it is now, I suspect - but I doubt it swayed the public's actual buying and reading habits all that much.