3 ms·
We did rethink the desktop, about twice on a large scale. MacOS tried a scorched-earth approach at supporting hardware, which allowed for a pretty impressive s
by smoldesu 5y ago
We did rethink the desktop, about twice on a large scale.
MacOS tried a scorched-earth approach at supporting hardware, which allowed for a pretty impressive software stack to be maintained with (relative) stability. The issue is that MacOS takes countless shortcuts to reach that final level of presentation. APFS is a mess compared to it's contemporary filesystems, and the entire underlying ethos behind getting an app to work on MacOS depends on how well you're willing to work with Apple and integrate into that central stack. Their idea of a desktop is one where the first party is in control, and they provision you permissions where they see fit.
Windows has to accommodate for a much larger pool of hardware, but also has the advantage of market dominance. Everyone develops for Windows because it powers more than 70% of consumer PCs. It's a no-brainer if you want the biggest audience possible. Microsoft also breaks from Apple in providing a much more robust compatibility layer for legacy software. It's reliance on antiquated internals also helps suppress newer technologies from entering the desktop. The Windows shell pared-back and lacking, even compared to most Linux desktop environments. Their idea of a desktop is one where the third parties are in control, and you provision them permission where you see fit.
I've seen people be productive with both, and I certainly can't knock them for being the predominant platforms, but I eventually just got fed up with fighting my computer to do basic tasks and switched to Linux. Everything is a file here, that's canon. Microsoft won't try to sell you more OneDrive storage, and Apple won't second guess your authority here either, since the user is sacred. It's that kind of dedication to simplicity that tips the scales in Linux's favor for me, and I can't imagine I'll be going back to Windows or MacOS until either of them show a similar dedication to empowering the user with simple tools.