4 ms·
And Vulcan are space elves, Klingon are space orcs and Borg are space undead. All of this stuff has inspiration from classical fantasy. That doesn't change whe
by dragontamer 5y ago
And Vulcan are space elves, Klingon are space orcs and Borg are space undead.
All of this stuff has inspiration from classical fantasy. That doesn't change whether or not something is SciFi or not.
There is an intersection of SciFi and Fantasy for sure, and the line gets blurred. Artificial human stories can be cyborgs, androids, clones, golems, or chimera, or even explicit fantasy races like minotaurs.
If it's an android, then it's SciFi. But if it was a clay golem made with magic (but otherwise the same story) it's fantasy.
See golem stories for instance. They explore a lot of sci Fi themes but are basically a fantasy theme. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golem
- ben_w 5y agoCertainly many tropes are shared, but that is true beyond the scifi-fantasy intersection. (Although: I would say Klingons are the avatar of Russian-ness in the eyes of America at the time any given episode gets written. Beardy humans in TOS, impoverished but hard as nails in TNG, anarchic and self-destructive in ENT, sneaky and dangerous warmongers in DIS). I regard the superhero genre as a modern version of the old divine pantheons — heroes and villains, supposedly far beyond human, yet oddly well-balanced against each other (Hawkeye should not be in the same battleground as Thor in the same way and for the same reason that Choi Mi-sun should not be in a battle featuring an attack helicopter). Sufficiently advanced technology being indistinguishable from magic and all that.
- nearbuy 5y agoI see the similarities for Klingons and Borg, but I don't see much similarity between Vulcans and elves beyond the pointy ears. Vulcans are more like androids: logical and outwardly emotionless, but not necessarily wise. The human captain (e.g. Kirk) tends to figure out a winning solution despite the resident Vulcan often complaining it isn't logical. That doesn't detract from your point.
- krapp 5y agoIIRC, Spock's appearance was intended to look vaguely demonic or Satanic, rather than like an elf. The original concept had him with red skin and deeply arched eyebrows as well, but they had to tone the makeup down a lot to avoid offending religious viewers.
- FuriouslyAdrift 5y agoIn the original series, the Vulcans were the Japanese, the Klingons the Soviets, and the Romulans the Chinese. The series was bathed in the politics and social struggles of the times (the late 60's).