3 ms·
But the question is, if you used a probabilistic approach, and tried to model, even very roughly, those things (probability contractor bodges the job in a way i
by londons_explore 5y ago
But the question is, if you used a probabilistic approach, and tried to model, even very roughly, those things (probability contractor bodges the job in a way inspection doesn't notice: 10%), then would you end up with a safer bridge for the same money spent?
- ghaff 5y agoIt feels like you're picking numbers out of the air (or basing them on historical experience) either way. Unless you actually have historical data on certain types of problems--but then it seems like you're pretty much back to a safety/fudge factor.
- londons_explore 5y agoBut a large number of guestimated fudge factors all added up will approach the true value as long as there is no bias. The same does not apply for factors of safety - a 1.5 FoS is always between 0 and 50% too much.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wiredfool 5y agoThat can be an unbounded black swan event. There are distributions where there is no mean value. The difference between a square section and welded channels. The difference between 53F and 27F. The difference between putting the waterproofing on before or after the post tensioning anchors. Leaving watertight doors open during a storm.