3 ms·
The real number engineers should be considering is not the factor of safety, but the probability of failure. The probably of failure should be calculated consi
by londons_explore 5y ago
The real number engineers should be considering is not the factor of safety, but the probability of failure.
The probably of failure should be calculated considering material defects, forces larger than predicted, simulation errors, and all other causes the factor of safety is designed to protect against.
Then the engineering process can allocate those probabilities in the most efficient way.
For example, in a rocket it might make sense to make the engine bells stronger (decreasing probably of failure) while making the fuel tanks weaker (increasing probability of failure). The overall probability of failure remains the same, but perhaps the craft ends up lighter/cheaper/better than it would be if all components just built in a fixed factor of safety.
- afterburner 5y agoUnfortunately, NASA was really bad at estimating the probability of failure. Feynman famously dissed their lack of mathematical rigour in this regard. I'm guessing most engineers' grasp of proper statistics math is worse than their understanding of factors of safety.
- mannykannot 5y agoIndeed, though my recollection of Feynman's most pertinent criticism is that he suspected that the probability of failure of the thousands of individual components - probabilities that are all very small numbers - were picked with one eye on how they moved the overall risk. He felt that the analysis, which should have been bottom-up (and nominally was) was actually conducted in a top-down manner. The space shuttle program demonstrated that if your analysis overlooks just one scenario (such as a rigid O-ring or ice on the bipod ramp), the risks can be much greater than you calculate.