3 ms·
For anyone looking to find real-time raytracing examples, this is not it. The author seems to be investigating static renders like you would do in Blender, offl
by smoldesu 5y ago
For anyone looking to find real-time raytracing examples, this is not it. The author seems to be investigating static renders like you would do in Blender, offloading it to the CPU instead of the GPU. Unsurprisingly, the M1 does not support hardware-accelerated ray tracing. However, almost any CPU made in the last 10 years is capable of software-accelerated ray tracing with software like Pixar's Renderman and the open-source Cycles engine.
- Cyberdog 5y ago> software-accelerated ray tracing Is this a particular term/concept, or do you just mean non-hardware-accelerated ray tracing? If the former, what does it mean for something to be "software-accelerated?" If the latter, I apologize if this comes off as nit-picking.
- smoldesu 5y agoWhen I say software-accelerated, I'm referring to anything that doesn't offload any rendering processes to the GPU. It's not necessarily a turn of phrase, but I think most people familiar with the topic will grok that software rendering = no GPU offload. Though I do understand the desire to be pedantic, because ISAs like this and their SIMD instructions can kinda blur the lines between what constitutes as "hardware accelerated". That's why I try to avoid it as much as possible for the sake of simplicity.
- tralarpa 5y agoI think parent was wondering what the word "accelated" in "software-accelerated" could mean. Faster than what? (faster doing the calculations by hand? :)
- dragontamer 5y agoThe concept of "accelerating" raytracing operations on a CPU makes almost no sense. GPUs require acceleration because the memory latency on GPUs is pretty large, caches are small, and GPUs have such huge compute that waiting around for the "next = bvh-tree->left" operation takes a huge amount of time. By making dedicated acceleration structures and hardware, that latency can be mitigated, and the huge compute capabilities of GPUs can be unleashed. ---------- In contrast, CPUs are already really good (relatively) at pointer-dereferencing loops. CPUs have less compute and more memory-optimizations (relative to a GPU anyway).
- CyberDildonics 5y ago> However, almost any CPU made in the last 10 years is capable of software-accelerated ray tracing with software like Pixar's Renderman and the open-source Cycles engine. People have been rendering on any CPU they could get their hands on for the last forty years and there is no such thing as "software accelerated ray tracing". That would be like someone saying their car does engine accelerated driving.
- numpad0 5y agoI propose “naturally forced induction”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Pulcinella 5y agoOctane, ProRender, and soon I believe Redshift on macOS use the Metal API for GPU based ray tracing. They are generally faster than CPU based ray tracing (well maybe not ProRender, it’s basically abandoned by Maxxon in favor of Redshift). So while the M1 GPU and most AMD GPUs supported by macOS don’t have hardware specific for accelerating ray tracing, they can still be used to accelerate it over using the CPU. Edit: The article does compare the ray tracing capabilities of the M1 GPU to a RTX 2070. The RTX 2070 obviously crushes it, as the author points out the obviously unfair comparison. The RTX card uses way more power, is much largerx and has hardware acceleration for ray tracing. I am interested in seeing if Apple adds hardware acceleration for RT to future chips (or if they will support external AMD GPUs).
- lostmsu 5y ago> The RTX card uses way more power, is much largerx and has hardware acceleration for ray tracing. Isn't RTX card using less power per ray according to this benchmark? This also applies to ray/size unit I think.
- VMtest 5y agoI have seen in old posts that people writing their own raytracers, and that normally means it's on CPU as well right? so their own raytracers are not real-time either