4 ms·
This week has been win/win/win for Putin and Lukashenko. The EU cutting ties with Belarus pushes the Belarussian people further into Russia's arms. Lukashenko g
by pydry 5y ago
This week has been win/win/win for Putin and Lukashenko. The EU cutting ties with Belarus pushes the Belarussian people further into Russia's arms. Lukashenko got to cast terror into the heart of the opposition movement.
Russia needs the countries on its European border. It is completely exposed militarily - flat lands leading all the way to its heartland routinely used by invaders. It already has two NATO countries on its border and another country (Ukraine) that has asked to join. The last thing it needs is a wall of NATO countries pressed up against its jugular.
Having Belarus on side is critical for them.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoCompletely exposed to who? The US? Germany? Lithuania? Who exactly is going to take advantage of this terrain and drive an army into Russia? Nobody, that's who. I'll tell you what Putin's really afraid of. He's afraid of Russians figuring out that the people in the USSR who wound up aligned with the west are better off than the people who are under Putin. He's afraid of that reality creeping too close to his borders. (Now, in fairness, it was absolutely absurd that France would invade Russia... until it happened. But if Putin wants buffers big enough to prevent that from happening, then he's going to need to control both Germany and France. There are no buffers big enough to disarm Russia's fears, unless you give them at least all of Europe. And maybe you'd have to give them the whole planet.)
- pydry 5y agoUh, NATO. NATO isn't an invading force, of course and is purely a defensive pact which is why they occupied Afghanistan.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI asked who's going to take advantage (militarily, in context) of this level terrain leading into Russia, and you say "NATO". And then you say that NATO isn't an invading force. So what, exactly, are you saying? Seems like you're back at my answer of "nobody is going to invade".
- lucian1900 5y agoI believe they were sarcastic about NATO not being an invading force by mentioning one of the more obvious invasions.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoAh, I see. You could also add Kosovo, if you chose. Still, my point stands: Is NATO going to invade Russia, using that favorable geography? No. Absolutely not. Zero chance. No NATO country has the stomach for a war of mass casualties, and nobody is stupid enough to think that an invasion of Russia would be anything else. (The good news is that, after Afghanistan, I don't think that Russia has the stomach for a war of mass casualties, either, and Putin knows it. So he plays games with "little green men" and the Wagner Group, but I don't think he can go much further than that. China concerns me more - I fear that at the moment, maybe they do have the stomach for it, and the temptation to try because they doubt that anyone else has the will to fight enough to give China that kind of casualties.)
- lucian1900 5y agoWhy would China want war? Isn’t it the US that constantly invades and occupies countries, not the other way around? It’s the US I fear, it already has bases all over my country.
- pydry 5y agoZero chance right now, yep. Russia is way too powerful militarily. If Lukashenko is overthrown and Belarus flips to the West, though, NATO will start to threaten Kaliningrad next. Maybe the Baltic Republican Party will get another truckload of cash out of nowhere and start giving interviews on CNN. The whole point of the ratchet games in Eastern Europe is to make it incrementally easier until it becomes a more realistic plan. NATO probably won't have a problem edging further towards Moscow for 70 more years and Moscow will try to stymie them every step of the way. Once it becomes realistic and winnable there's a good chance they won't need to fight. Russia would likely flip to becoming a client state of the US of its own accord. That is likely the NATO endgame - a series of puppets like Yeltsin in power for good with the labor/natural resource markets opened up for exploitation to American megacorporations, no significant industrial base of its own and a very limited military capacity.
- perl4ever 5y agoAfghanistan does not seem like an example of favorable geography. Plus, which adjoining country was Afghanistan invaded from, such that a larger buffer would have helped?
- pydry 5y agoIt doesn't no, which underscores the importance of favorable geography to successful military action even when you hold overwhelming military power. Afghanistan was poor and the government was militarily weak, though, which I guess is why the US figured they could execute a successful military invasion in spite of the geographical unfavorability. Osama was definitely on to something when he baited the US into a war there. He said the war would be protracted, costly, deadly and unwinnable. $2.5 trillion down the drain and 4,000 deaths later and nothing to show for it - he was right.
- _ph_ 5y agoWhether it was a right decision or not, NATO only invaded Afghanistan after 9/11 which was considered an attack onto a member state. This was done purely to fight the terrorist regime and never as a permanent occupation. And NATO is currently leaving Afghanistan completely - after which of course the Taliban are going back to their old ways, which of course are also bad for the population.
- pydry 5y agoAfghanistan got invaded after asking for evidence that 9/11 was caused by bin Laden before handing him over. The US decided that evidence was not required (& didn't really have any anyway at that point) and invaded. These are not the actions of a defensive pact acting defensively. They're the act of a country with bloodlust.
- _ph_ 5y agoThat the NATO would invade Russia is a bizarre idea. They simply have no incentive, and even if they had any interest, they are lacking the troops and Russia is a nuclear power. If it were not, the west would probably have engaged more forcefully in Ukraine, especially as they had signed contracts to do so when Ukraine gave up their nuclear weapons.
- pydry 5y agoSeriously? NATO's entire existence was borne out of a desire to lock horns with Moscow. They didn't supply troops to Ukraine cos they don't want a direct fight with another nuclear power. This was a defining feature of the cold war. That's why it was called "cold". What makes you think this time is different? It's much lower risk and much cheaper to play the long game and stir up ethnic tensions along exposed borders and foment ethnic and cultural splits. This being famously effective at building and sustaining the British Empire and also something Russia is trying to do to the US with social media, although with limited success beyond sparking thanksgiving arguments.
- _ph_ 5y agoA nice term you are using, "lock horns". Nicely vague, says anything or nothing. Yes, the NATO was founded as a counterpart to the expanding Sovjet Union. Which was not a democratic state but had a de-factor dictator in control and prevented independent democracies in the states of the Warshaw Pact. Whereever there were democratic movements in those states, they even sent troups to help swish them. They also had a huge amount (many thousands) of battle tanks ready at the western border of the Warshaw Pact region. Whereas the NATO only had a much smaller tank force ready. So there was never the risk of a conventional attack of the NATO against the Warshaw Pact region. You are right, the NATO didn't support the Ukraine with military equipment or even troups, despite of the treaty, because of the fear of things going nuclear. That is also the reason any allegations about the NATO attacking Russia is pure sillyness. The only "danger" for Russia, or rather Putin, is, that more and more countries want to be independant, especially for improving economic ties to the west, as this brings economic prosperity. It is tragic, how the enourmeous wealth of Russia, thanks to its oil and gas, was wasted for fancy yachts instead of boosting the industrial upbuild of the country.