3 ms·
>It makes sure we calculate the loads correctly and use appropriate materials. No, it make sure that nobody dies when you calculate the loads incorrectly and u
by whatshisface 5y ago
>It makes sure we calculate the loads correctly and use appropriate materials.
No, it make sure that nobody dies when you calculate the loads incorrectly and use inappropriate materials.
- rossdavidh 5y agoI think the idea is that, if you calculate the load incorrectly enough, or use inappropriate enough materials, the safety factor will not save you. But, if you have done those things correctly, then the safety factor should be enough to save you from normal unknowns, unexpecteds, etc.
- Gibbon1 5y agoYeah four things going on. Design errors Probabilistic nature of the loads applied. Material defects Fatigue Deterioration All structures have a service life and it's the service lifetime an experienced engineer is trying to hit. For the impeller in a rocket turbo pump the service life is like 5 minutes. For the impeller in a hydro electric dam it's 50 years. The other thing that one of my professors pointed out was that 80% of engineers end up designing once off designs. Where the NRE cost is a lot more than the material costs. Shaving the safety factor is false economy.
- wiml 5y agoAlso helps when management decides to defer maintenance for a decade or two and someone drives a truck over it that's just a bit over the weight limit what could it hurt?
- whatshisface 5y agoPerhaps implicit institutional knowledge of large safety factors is why management feels safe deferring maintenance.
- iscrewyou 5y agoCan’t tell if this is sarcasm. Because of goal of civil engineering is building man made objects with public safety in mind.
- zdragnar 5y agoAnother way to look at factor of safety is margin for error. Implementation variance, material variance, etc can all go wrong if something is designed to be exactly safe. You need to know that something is redundantly safe, and which parts.
- LegitShady 5y agoMaterial variances are included where the capacity is calculated. materials with hIgher variance like concrete (implementation variance) and wood (material variance) get their capacity lowered more than more consistent materials like steel. The factor of safety is above and beyond material variance. You calculate the worst case load combinations for that component, then you check your factor of safety. Civil engineering is relatively conservative in its estimations for everyone's safety. In my experience serviceability requirements (like reducing uncomfortable deflections that dont threaten the safety of the structure) often govern, rather than the ultimate capacity.