4 ms·
I wonder if the Russians would have managed to get the N1 under control if Sergei Korolev had still been around to lead the project. As far as I understand it,
by flohofwoe 5y ago
I wonder if the Russians would have managed to get the N1 under control if Sergei Korolev had still been around to lead the project. As far as I understand it, the Russian moon project suffered heavily from political bickering after Korolev's death, and the technological problems might have been a direct result.
- ghaff 5y agoCertainly his death didn't help things. But, as far as I can tell, the consensus was that it was a much too complex (too many engines) approach for the time. So it's not clear that once they took that direction, they'd have been able to recover in a reasonable timeframe.
- avmich 5y agoMy guess Korolev would perhaps see earlier than others (he died January 1966) that the current trajectory - 95 tons payload of N1 with 30 engines on the first stage - is too risky, and would turn things significantly. For example, coming back to 75 tons N1 and dealing with more dockings on orbit. That would at least reduce number of engines on the first stage; maybe not a very good idea though. Or coming back to another idea, having N2 (which is N1 without first stage) a priority and fly to the Moon with ideas his team had before (in 50-s? there was a plan with multiple dockings and refuelings, which would use more modest rockets, but N2 with ~25 tons of payload would certainly help). N2 was even in a better tested state - it was the first stage of N1 which was the most problematic. Or making even better with Chelomei (Korolev approved project Zond, which was a kind of joined project between two design bureaus) and use Proton for multi-launch schemas. Plenty of opportunities. If Korolev would be lucky enough to avoid Komarov's death, Russians would have some spare time - in addition to momentum - to move things forward.