3 ms·
China (and India) are dealing with population numbers never before seen, at a scale that is inconceivable without special training or focus (whats the differenc
by roenxi 5y ago
China (and India) are dealing with population numbers never before seen, at a scale that is inconceivable without special training or focus (whats the difference between a million and a billion? about a billion). It is a mathematical possibility that growth rates overshoot and settle into patterns of boom and bust - and a bust in human populations can get really ugly.
"It hasn't happened in the last 2 centuries" isn't an argument against Malthusian collapses either. China has a long memory.
I have a lot of sympathy for the argument that the One-child Policy was a mistake. In my view, it was. But I also have a lot of sympathy for the people who implemented it. As ideas go it isn't an obvious mis-step in the class as, say, Communist economic policies.
- baybal2 5y agoThey deserve no sympathy, it was sheer madness, and it is. > As ideas go it isn't an obvious mis-step in the class as, say, Communist economic policies. No, it's an exemplary case of completely bonker policies in rank with "4 pests" campaign. Sadly, stuff like that is very much intentional, and are signature of Maoesque political thought: You intentionally make populace outraged over something very obvious, and then keep obsessing over it for no reason making people think it's a big thing, when it isn't. When people people have something more close, personal, and painful to be outraged about, it shifts people's attention from an even more obvious fact of complete governance failure, and communist occupation of the country.