9 ms·
After years of conflict and instability, Iraq is opening up to tourism
- colpabar 5y agoI bet some western tourists would get a kick out of some kind of joke "weapons of mass destruction" attraction. I don't know if any Iraqi people would though.
- whatshisface 5y agoThe red carpet leads up to a huge vault door. The carnie promises you the sight of your life. You tell all your friends and bring them along. Your buddy Dubois stays home, and you resent him for it. The vault door opens, and you walk around the corner. You see a roped-in platform. The platform is empty and the carnie is gone. The price of admission: two trillion dollars. The door is now locked from the outside.
- vmception 5y agoThis reminds me how I used to smooth out people's extreme views of areas and regimes: One day your child will be going on a senior trip to Disneyland Iraq and your protest against it will simply make you look like the old prejudiced bigot. Nobody will care that you were fed propaganda and also reality for 20 years straight. No different than our parents, grandparents or refugees having haunting views of other countries that are major allies now.
- calvinmorrison 5y agoReminds me of the Mad Men scene where the old guy is in a conference with a Japanese firm and freaks out, still mentally fighting the war, while everyone else stares at him like he's crazy
- sebmellen 5y agoThough I understand your point, “Disneyland Iraq” still sounds like an extremely remote possibility.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoI'm sure Tokyo Disneyland sounded extremely unlikely forty years before it opened.
- Apocryphon 5y agoMight be Netflixland by then.
- bloaf 5y agoWhile possible, it is equally possible that the Iraq of 30 years from now is just as unsafe for LGBTQ people as it is today.
- ixacto 5y agoYes but we don’t know. Saudi Arabia could be a secular dictatorship/kingdom similar to Turkey or Syria by then. Iraq might be much more inclusive by then. Then again Turkey could go full Islamist crazy and be more Saudi Arabia and Erdoğan could declare himself president for life. But I think globalization will somewhat liberalize all of the above in the coming years, and the desire to fit in and do business globally will push for liberalization.
- belatw 5y ago> Then again Turkey could go full Islamist crazy and be more Saudi Arabia and Erdoğan could declare himself president for life. It would never happen. Turks are Turks first and Muslim second. Erdogan is a neo-ottomanist, not a salafist. He’s as much of a Muslim as Trump is a Christian. Now I do see him trying to sell more of the nation to Saudis and Emirates while also forcing enough pro-sunni legislation down our throats to keep the Conservative / Nationalists happy and ensure that Saudi / Qatari investment coming and to ensure he can profit like a bandit off of his pre-doomed “Islamic Finance” initiatives. However, Turks are fairly centrist by American standards. They drink, a lot (alcohol tax revenue is crucial to the government, as well as direct sales as the government still owns some of the Raki and Beer production), smoke weed, party, are getting married and having children later in life, and fewer. I watched the sweaty shirtless guys beating mislead soldiers to death during the failed coup a few years ago. They weren’t shouting allahu akbar while they did it. They waved Ataturk flags and sang the Izmir march.
- bloaf 5y agoClimate change is real, and oil is in decline. These countries will only become harder to live in, and their incomes will only decline. That these countries will modernize and liberalize in the face of these challenges is not at all a foregone conclusion.
- throwaway894345 5y agoIs the implication that Islamic terrorist groups operating in Iraq were propagandist fiction? That the real reason westerners fear Iraq is bigotry? I’m specifically unfamiliar with “grandparents and refugees having haunting views of other countries”. I have grandfathers who served in WWII and Korea and they don’t have any particular antipathy for Germans or Koreans. I’m not really familiar with that meme.
- the_only_law 5y agoIf Islamic terrorist groups were a major factor in destroying and destabilizing a country it’s a wonder Saudi Arabia is still standing.
- throwaway894345 5y agoWhat does “destroying and destabilizing a country” have to do with the premise (fear of traveling to Iraq)? Genuine question.
- the_only_law 5y agoApologies, missed the parent and misread the context.
- edgyquant 5y agoIsn’t the answer oil money? I know it’s been said a lot that the KSA has a serious fundamentalist problem but they are able to basically bribe the large parts of their populace that would otherwise turn the country upside down.
- vmception 5y agoThe answer to your first question is no. It's still up to you to figure out which parts were propaganda and which parts were reality. The only distinction between a terrorist group or otherwise is sovereign immunity, if you succeed in getting a state then you aren't a terrorist anymore by definition of having political goals met. And the answer to everything else is now you are familiar with the meme. Enjoy the new valid experience you went your whole life unaware of.
- exo-pla-net 5y agoIt's almost like countries comprise human beings with varying attitudes, and the fanatics don't speak for everybody, much less the kids currently being born.
- jgilias 5y agoThere are only a few dozen countries that allow people to express those attitudes, or even recognize the right of people to harbor varying attitudes in the first place. No matter how much you might not believe in God, there are plenty of places where your life will be in danger for expressing that attitude, so you don't.
- jacobwilliamroy 5y agoI regularly play Arab pop music at parties: Nancy Ajram, Amr Diab, Mohammed Assaf.
- pjc50 5y agoI think you're being a bit obtuse about a perfectly reasonable point that yes, someday the war is over and the other side becomes entirely normal. It happened relatively quickly with Germany, in fact maybe quicker than the rehabilitation of Iraq. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sister_city https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sister_city (well, West Germany anyway!) On the other hand, the war has to end first. Some simply haven't. Europe's oldest frozen warzone is still there, the Green Line across Cyprus. The tourist resort of Nicosia is still a no man's land. https://artsandculture.google.com/story/the-green-line-nicosia-s-urban-no-man-s-land/ https://artsandculture.google.com/story/the-green-line-nicos...
- DSingularity 5y agoThe West should pay reparations to Iraq for both the illegal war and all the war crimes.
- papito 5y agoPlenty of suitcases full of cash travelled to Iraq when the neocons were looting the treasury during the project. It's not like that money is going to go to the right people anyway - but nice houses will be built.
- spankyspangler 5y agoThe problem with this corporatist neoleftist thinking is that "the west" are the victims too. Thousands and thousands of people in "the west" were killed or horribly damaged by the war. And they were forced to pay trillions of dollars for it. And like clockwork, the elites will tell those people they are to blame for it, they must pay reparations, they must bear more burden of taking refugees, etc. The actual people who should pay reparations are the war profiteers and those who lied and committed crimes to start these wars.
- papito 5y ago"Clashes between security forces and protesters left one person dead and over a dozen injured Tuesday after hundreds of Iraqis took to the streets in Baghdad to protest a rise in targeted killings of prominent activists and journalists."[1] Cool. [1] https://apnews.com/article/iraq-middle-east-health-coronavirus-pandemic-5e6ea0c4057e4d69731c8189435ea373 https://apnews.com/article/iraq-middle-east-health-coronavir...
- dang 5y ago"Don't be snarky." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- colechristensen 5y agoHow often could something like that be written about an event in an american city? I’m not trying to say there’s equivalent danger, but these kinds of things happen all over the world even in “safe” places.
- Apocryphon 5y agoSounds similar to what's been happening in certain cities of Colombia this past month. And that country is still a tourist hotspot.
- peteretep 5y agoWorth remembering that visiting there (or Iran) will mean your ESTA privileges are revoked, and you’ll need a visa to travel to ‘merika.
- usrme 5y agoThis was news to me and it turns out that this is indeed the case: https://e-visa.ie/usa/news/iran-and-esta https://e-visa.ie/usa/news/iran-and-esta. They mention the 1st of March, 2011 as the cut off point, but I haven't been able to suss out why it's that date exactly. I'm guessing it has to do with the Arab Spring, but that is just conjecture. Hopefully someone can correct me if I am way off base.
- fsloth 5y agoHoly moley, thanks for the heads up! Your comment should be the top comment, given the business of business which for us non-US citizens still requires often interacting with the said polity! Also - US, hello? That kind of sucks. Tourism would be a great way to integrate these areas more to the "western" spheres of business (I'm not saying that is a valuable value as such, I take no sides, but I presume US would consider this still advantageous to it's positioning). When I read this news I immediately thought I could go and visit the ruins of Babylon (yes, I can go and see pieces of it museums in non-ESTA-nulling places but it's not the same thing). Now - ancient babylon vs. ESTA privileges? Oh man, choices, choices.
- bassdropvroom 5y agoI'm European-Kurd, and had to travel to Kurdistan Region (northern Iraq) for my sister's wedding a few years before I had to go to the US. I was denied my ESTA without a refund (it was $20 iirc, so not a huge amount but as someone who had just graduated, every penny counted for me) due to this exemption. Had to get a full visitors visa to go which took a lot longer, and was way more expensive. The exemption, which was put in place due to ISIS in 2013, seems reasonable though unfortunate.
- verelo 5y agoYears back i seriously considered an Iran trip out of general curiosity about the region. It quickly became clear this would inhibit future travel to the US so i figured it wasn’t worth the trouble. Super disappointing, it would be cool to see the area.
- dang 5y agoAll: please avoid cheap comments about inflammatory issues. If you have something thoughtful to say, say it substantively; otherwise, please don't post it here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Mediterraneo10 5y agoIt should be noted that tourism to Iraq's Kurdistan province has been going on for years, with a steady stream of backpackers entering from Turkey. That region is autonomously governed and has been relatively spared the violence of the rest of the country. But the opening of tourism to the south of the country is a surprising development.
- sebmellen 5y agoGreat video on that by Yes Theory here: https://youtu.be/TWRlPKMAkRk https://youtu.be/TWRlPKMAkRk.
- blueblisters 5y agoThat was a great video, thanks for the share!
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoThis. I agree, I’ve been there 3 times during the war against ISIS (as a journalist) and I was really surprised about the Kurdistan. Very nice!
- amerine 5y agoAs an American, how could I plan and arrange for a travel visit? Is there a service that can arrange everything for me?
- ipaddr 5y agoOpening up for tourism would imply flights probably to a major city.
- Haemm0r 5y agoe.g. direct flight VIE-EBL(mainly due Austrian to involvement in the oil business in the region) or Istanbul-EBL is served regularly.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoAs an American who has been traveling for over 18 months now, I have two suggestions: - find & join an expat group on Facebook to ask questions like this - consider not over planning and just go, figuring it out when you’re there, as I promise you there will be plenty of locals willing to arrange things for you when you get there - for a place like Iraq, the hardest part might be getting cash. I was in Pakistan last year and a lot of the ATMs wouldn’t work with my debit card. Eventually I found one. Just don’t assume you’ll be able to pay with a Visa card everywhere. In Pakistan I simply sent myself a bunch of money via Western Union. - register with the State Department’s STEP program if you go.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoAs an European journalist I’ve been to Iraq, Mosul and Sinjar during the war 3 times in 2014-17-18. I’m a photographer, here are my reportages www.giuliomagnifico.it (under reportage menu). The north Iraq (Kurdistan region) is a wonderful place for tourist! I absolutely suggest to go there, with all the precautions of course. If you need something, just ask me. I’ve got some contacts/friends in Kurdistan.
- stevoski 5y ago> The north Iraq (Kurdistan region) is a wonderful place for tourist! I've been there, as a backpacking tourist. "A wonderful place for tourist" is overselling it, I think.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoBeauty is subjective but the people are very friendly, there aren’t other tourists and the city like Erbil are very very nice IMO. Here I’ve uploaded(G. Photos) some “stupid/phone” photos from my last trip to Iraq: https://photos.app.goo.gl/TrRVhH6uDAmMU5cNA https://photos.app.goo.gl/TrRVhH6uDAmMU5cNA so you can view that there are a lot of tourists attractions and beautiful places!
- tidenly 5y agoWhats the man talking about in the video with the children? Liked the pics though - would be up for going if I had a guide. I feel like it's like when I went around rural China a bit, if you dont have a native its easy to get turned about or stuck!
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoBest photos are on my website, those are quite stupid photos just for documents the trip. The man is talking about the injuries of the little girl caused by the ISIS during the genocide. She was escaped from ISIS. If you need I can send you the contact I’ve used in Iraq. He’s a friendly student/guy :-)
- josefrichter 5y agoI am one of those who’d seriously consider going. I was even watching many videos of people traveling to the region. One big disadvantage is that once you go there, you won’t get ESTA to the US and would have to go thru lengthy visa process. And I’m afraid you’d be getting more attention in general, unfortunately.
- kweks 5y agoFor what it's worth, Kurdistan, the north of Iraq has been open for tourism for many years. Kurdistan is the semi-autonomous region of Iraq, whose capital is Erbil. I've been through twice, the first time at possibly the the 'worst' time - just after the rise of ISIS in Mossul, and when the US was bombing just south of Erbil. Despite initial concerns, safety was never a problem. I felt safe; did not feel like an unwelcome presence, and moreover, it was an incredible experience. No visa is required, you get stamped in at the border. The police and Pershmerga were kind, dutiful and not overbearing. Although it's a sliver of the rest of the country, there are many very interesting things to see (the spiritual centre of the Yzidi, Erbil, the mountains to the North, etc etc). Kurdistan is secular, with a mix of ethnicities and religions. There is at least one third of women who do not wear the hijab, and the burqua is rare. (You see more burquas in the east of Turkey). My second visit was during Ramadan, and I was surprised to see people drinking alcohol in the streets and bars. (Please note, I don't consider a country's "modernity" by its acceptation of alcohol. The point is more that there is a deep culture of tolerance and acceptance within Kurdistan, which can be demonstrated with examples such as the consumption of alcohol). In regards to losing rights to travel under ESTA, I have visited the US since without issue, even with an Iraqi stamp in the passport. With that said, I imagine that simply replacing your passport after a trip would be a workable solution as well. Photos for the interested: http://travel.ninjito.com/2014-08-10-Kurdistan http://travel.ninjito.com/2014-08-10-Kurdistan http://www.ninjito.com/2019-05-15-Iraq http://www.ninjito.com/2019-05-15-Iraq
- smcl 5y agoHow did you find getting around outside the cities (or between them)? Did you hire a car, or a driver, or was there good enough public transport?
- kweks 5y agoThe first time I had my motorbike. Second time just hired a car. Car hire from the airport is quick and easy (it's Hertz). Without transport, you'd be severely limited I'd say, but it depends how you like to travel.
- kweks 5y agoFor anyone considering visiting this region, or any regions with potential conflict (or anyone with an interest in 'raw Intel', https://liveuamap.com/ https://liveuamap.com/ is a vital resource. Borders and zones are classed green/yellow/orange/red, incidents (ranging from protests to bombings) are in realtime. It allows for pragmatic decisions relating to movement than the standard news channels.
- nickdothutton 5y agoIran has good relations with the Arab Shia elite currently attempting to govern in Iraq. Iraq is today as it was in antiquity, the key to greater Iranian influence throughout the region. You might want to consider that before funding that government with your tourist dollar.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gherkinnn 5y agoThere's barely a place on earth where you don't fund $OBJECTIONABLE with your tourist dollars. On the other hand, being within the Iranian sphere of influence might grant you access to delicious food [0] 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_cuisine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_cuisine
- austincheney 5y agoI remember my tourism moment in northern Baghdad in 2010. I actually flew there from Kuwait to take a scheduled CISSP exam. I got to tour palace row on Camp Liberty. I got lost the evening I arrived which made me nervous because I recently paid $700 to attend this exam the next morning despite sleeping only about 2 hours and using almost the full 6 hours of test time I still passed (first time go). I remember the enormous catfish in the largest palace moat and the bats swarm from the local bat tower at night. That large palace was truly exquisite with tall brilliant marble walls and gold lettering in-laid. I also remember the Flintstones palace for Saddam’s grandchildren. Then I spent a week at Balad playing Guitar Hero awaiting transportation back to Kuwait.
- WinstonSmith84 5y agoIraq is taking tourists for cash cow. 0.01€ for the shared mini-bus, then what we've got to hire a driver for $100 / day and sleeps in a $200 hotel!?
- sonthonax 5y agoI’d advise against this unless you have an insane appetite for risk. The problem with going there as a white tourist (and not a Turkish backpacker) is that you will look like you belong in some way to coalition forces. This poses a kidnapping risk in a country that doesn’t have a functional legal system, but also has a internal passport system enforced by semi-state militias. Problem is, if something does go wrong, it is not entirely clear who’s responsibility it is to get you out. Your life is not necessarily in danger, but if anything does go wrong you’re in deep shit. But if you want to see Abbasid and Mesopotamian ruins all the power to you. Just remember, you’re going to be in rural areas with a very flakey state. Iraq isn’t a poor country either, it’s just incredibly poorly managed. You’ll find the food and hotels there surprisingly expensive and bad. Bribes will also cost you western sums. Infuriatingly, if you’re American you might even be committing a federal crime by giving one demanded at a checkpoint. One thing that’s properly weird about getting an Iraqi visa is that the process is like stepping back into the late 70s. The USA disbanded rather than reformed the civil service (before it engorged itself to an absurd size post civil war again) but what’s left of it is properly dysfunctional and dated. Another thing now that precludes actually going is that there are regular ‘lockdowns’ ostensibly for COVID, but are just really an excuse to stymie protests.
- tinus_hn 5y agoHow’s the covid situation over there? Is it under control and are they ready to accept the risks that tourists bring?