Right. He directly violates the HN rules, and I get modded down. He posted a dismissive snark about my (substantive) comment, and I replied in kind. Edit: For

Right. He directly violates the HN rules, and I get modded down. He posted a dismissive snark about my (substantive) comment, and I replied in kind. Edit: For the record, I've read plenty of papers in both Nature and Science, so his claim that I haven't is objectively incorrect. My response stands: he doesn't know what he's talking about.