3 ms·
Interesting to consider that a Jonbar Hinge is entirely predicated on the existence of free will.
by gmaster1440 5y ago
Interesting to consider that a Jonbar Hinge is entirely predicated on the existence of free will.
- Sniffnoy 5y agoNo, it just requires counterfactuals to be meaningful.
- gmaster1440 5y agoI agree. In my mind, counterfactuals are only meaningful if there’s free will. Something else could’ve happened iff you could’ve done or chosen otherwise.
- Sniffnoy 5y agoNo, counterfactuals are basically a separate matter. For instance, we can ask questions like "What if Lee Harvey Oswald's gun had jammed?" This doesn't involve any free will; it just involves the ability to work forward from a state that didn't actually occur.