3 ms·
It's a revealing bit of contemporary criticism, but it comes across as a bit naive, as if the author somehow expected something different from an author of popu
by CamperBob2 5y ago
It's a revealing bit of contemporary criticism, but it comes across as a bit naive, as if the author somehow expected something different from an author of popular spy fiction and was disappointed. He's not wrong, he just misses the point. Of course Bond is a head case whose psychological foibles are a reflection of his creator, or at least of his era. A woke Bond would be about as interesting (and about as profitable) as a woke Batman.
And as for Fleming's predilection for writing about card games and golf games: if you can make those interesting -- and he could, and did -- you're certainly entitled to be listed among the ranks of Real Writers. That's when I realized it was time to take Stephen King seriously -- not when he wrote interesting stories about vampires or demons or aliens, but when he wrote interesting stories about baseball.
Edit: on finishing the essay, I'm being too generous to the author here. His rambling about an anti-Semitic subtext in Fleming's books has no justification, and he knows it, which is why he starts rambling about anti-Semitic subtexts in other authors' works.
- woodruffw 5y ago> It's a revealing bit of contemporary criticism, but it comes across as a bit naive, as if the author somehow expected something different from an author of popular spy fiction and was disappointed. Well, John le Carré had already published at least 4 popular spy novels by the time (1968) this critique of Fleming was published. I, for one, think it's fair to expect something different when other contemporaneous authors were doing something different.
- B1FF_PSUVM 5y ago> John le Carré had already published at least 4 popular spy novels By the time I read my tenth or twelfth le Carré, I was ready to contest the point that they were different novels. It all seemed to boil down to "It's a mistake, we don't know what we are doing, woe is us" in different locales.
- woodruffw 5y agoThat's been my experience of them as well :-) They're certainly a different subgenre, but I think the larger point stands: it's possible to be a British author of spy novels in the 20th century without sublimating your fear of British decline through one-dimensional, reactionary characterization.
- CamperBob2 5y agoYeah, le Carré is to Fleming as David Attenborough is to J.R.R. Tolkien. They are not in the same business.