6 ms·
Could hacking be done in the public interest?
- zerop 15y agoIt could be... The NIC servers of Govt of India were hacked by Anonymous India (#OpIndia) to mark protest against the huge corruption in India http://www.thehackernews.com/2011/06/anonymous-india-opindia-strikes-again.html http://www.thehackernews.com/2011/06/anonymous-india-opindia...
- basseq 15y agoYou can't merely say that an illegal act is justified because it was conducted to expose another crime (or immoral action, or what-have-you). "Suspicions", even commonly held ones, do not suffice as burden of proof -- hence Constitutional amendments on unwarranted search and seizure, or outcry over racial profiling and illegal immigration. Can I break into my neighbors house because I think he's beating his wife? If not, then why is his computer system not sacrosanct as well? And if so, then aren't we advocating vigilantism? And if he is, in fact, guilty, then am I absolved of B&E? What if he's innocent; am I protected by the "purity" of my purpose? Conversely, the whistleblower regulation comparison is an interesting one, though my understanding is that it's designed to expose corruption where there is no external proof: you have to be an insider to have access to (or even aware of) the incriminating information. But in an age where information is public, and so too may be the indicators of crime. And in that case, might an outsiders' crime (e.g., hacking) parallel that of an insiders' (e.g., breach of confidential information), and, if conducted for the same purpose and with the same outcome, be afforded the same protection under the law? But this raises the question: if the information is public, then shouldn't we expect the authorities, if the suspicion is sufficient for a warrant, to conduct their own (legal) inquiry? Is this a simple failing of law enforcement? Or (tinfoil hat time) corruption at the "highest levels"? Or a fundamental shift in power (and, perhaps, responsibility) to the common man and the court of public opinion? Heavy questions. Could it be done in the public interest? Of course. Is it morally (or legally) justified? Perhaps. But maybe the real question: are the so-called hacker/advocacy groups somehow noble in their purpose? This, I doubt -- at least to date.
- jgrahamc 15y ago> Are the so-called hacker/advocacy groups somehow noble in > their purpose? This, I doubt -- at least to date. I totally agree with this. We've seen a number of groups (Anonymous, LulzSec) claiming to be noble but exposing tons of private information on 'innocent' individuals with the flimsy justification that that was showing that companies had poor security.
- nantes 15y agoI was kind of disappointed after the first paragraph, when I realized this wasn't talking about the kind of hacker I thought, as in Hacker News. If it were, it surely would have mentioned some awesome projects like: Hack Tyler http://hacktyler.com/ http://hacktyler.com/ Civic Commons http://civiccommons.org/ http://civiccommons.org/ Code for America http://codeforamerica.org/ http://codeforamerica.org/ and Open Plans http://openplans.org/ http://openplans.org/
- canistr 15y agoTo answer this question: Yes. And it happens at the NSA everyday when they are monitoring suspected criminals whether they are terrorists planning attacks, foreign spies conducting industrial or economic espionage, drug dealers trafficking banned substances, pedophiles, and other similar criminal activities. This should come as no surprise to anyone that the NSA or FBI does contain the money, manpower, and legal authority to do things 'in the public interest'. Patriotic hackers are a different matter and though they tend to hide within the underground, they often times are contracted by authorities to gather information or sabotage other more devious hackers. EDIT: And of course, someone has to downvote me because they disagree with me pointing out what is already happening. I don't understand how you can disagree with facts.
- bh42222 15y agoWait, so if the government breaks the law (I'm assuming you meant illegal hacking, otherwise never mind) they must be doing it for the right reasons and it is great and admirable and wonderful. But if private individuals illegally hack someone, not for profit, but to release information about cronyism, corruption, lax security, then those private hackers are just schmucks? This is then similar to how if the government tortures a suspect, that's OK because he might really be guilty. But obviously torture is wrong if anyone else does it?
- canistr 15y agoNo, I'm clearly talking about legal hacking. That's the whole point of "public interest".
- bh42222 15y agoDo you need a court order to legally hack, like a search warrant?
- canistr 15y agoUnder wiretapping laws, yes. But unlike some search warrants, they don't have to be presented to the person under investigation nor do the warrants have to be confirmed to be in use by authorities because that would compromise the investigations.
- tobylane 15y agoYes, with permission. It's called white hat. The way the (UK) law is phrased, permission makes the difference between legal and illegal, there isn't a grey area. The recent hacks, how else could they have been done? Does it really matter that Lulzsec did it rather than criminals who would sell the details on? This way guaranteed continuous reason/blame/motive, which is good press-wise.
- blendergasket 15y agoI would argue that the opening up of HPGary's emails was most definitely in the public interest even though not legal. We learned that private, unaccountable security firms were being contracted by the government and corporations to circumvent the checks and balances to power that the US Constitution and Bill of Rights provide us as citizens. Also, it showed that HPGary was willing to try to intimidate journalists into disown their positions and not defending organizations they felt a moral responsibility to protect: http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2011/02/11/campaigns http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2011/02/11... . More generally we are in a time of unprecedented attacks on the ability of the media to perform its role as a check to Power of all sorts: (Guy who exposed waste/corruption in NSA getting constantly harassed) http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/05/23/110523fa_fact_mayer http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/05/23/110523fa_fact_... (NYT writer subpoenaed before grand jury to give up source) http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/national-security/reporters-ordeal-continues-in-convoluted-cia-case/2011/07/03/gHQAbFDAyH_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/national-security/rep... (ATF agent fired for exposing that the ATF was actually selling Druglords guns) http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/06/the-obama-administrations-whistleblower-problem/241262/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/06/the-obam... (bit from The Corporation about Fox news bowing to Monsanto's desire to cover up the dangers of rGBH in milk) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JL1pKlnhvg0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JL1pKlnhvg0 The more the government and Power in general tries to cut citizens off from the information we need to make informed decisions the more activists are going to try to get this info by extrajudicial means. The farther we slide into a world where Corporate power and Government power no longer act as checks to one another and form a united front against anyone who challenges their blanket of unchecked power the more important it will be for some force(s) to stand up to them on behalf of the people's rights, including their right to information. I'm not justifying what News of the World did, there is no moral basis for playing with the emotions of the family of that poor girl in order to get an edge on more moral news gathering organizations. Hacking is a tool just like leaking is a tool. Both are used for good and bad. The problem is when both are used solely by the people in power to control to hurt the little guy.
- nathanb 15y agoPrivate citizens, at least in the US, are protected from government intrusion without the executive branch proving probable cause to the judicial branch. This is a part of the checks and balances which keep our government from becoming a totalitarian state, no matter how much it seems to want to. No matter how illogical and unreasonable it seems to reject concrete evidence of wrongdoing because said evidence was improperly obtained, such procedure is absolutely vital in order to keep from becoming a police state. While hacktivism can serve the useful purpose of keeping corporations and public officials honest, it also violates this fundamental tenet of our free society. While it seems very poetic and underdogish for a small hacker group to bring a huge, corrupt corporation to public humiliation, it is at the same time a terrifying incidence of vigilante justice. These corporations must be protected from this sort of thing by the law for the same reason that improperly-obtained evidence must be inadmissible in a court of law.
- saulrh 15y agoThe counterargument, as presented by blendergasket below, comes when the situation is reversed and the government is the target. Consider the recent #antisec releases as a sort of first-amendment freedom of the press, or the attacks on HBGary as people exercising their second amendment right to keep and bear arms.
- nathanb 15y agoIs the solution then to legalize such intrusions? It seems like it would be far too difficult to differentiate between beneficial and malevolent operations. It would also be extremely difficult for a company to dispute falsified evidence presented by would-be hacktivists. If anon had falsified the HBGary records, would we believe Aaron Barr if he said the data were not correct? How could he suitably prove the non-existence of such data to the public without revealing an inappropriate amount of internal information? I'm not saying such intrusions and releases are not useful or never reveal important information. But it's sort of like a Crime and Punishment situation. Even if the releases reveal important information about government or corporate corruption which would have otherwise gone unchecked, we cannot officially and legally condone these attacks.