3 ms·
> Still, the bill includes a provision that could make overturning an election easier. Texas election law had stated that reversing the results of an election b
by klyrs 5y ago
> Still, the bill includes a provision that could make overturning an election easier. Texas election law had stated that reversing the results of an election because of fraud accusations required proving that illicit votes had actually resulted in a wrongful victory. If the bill passes, the number of fraudulent votes required to do so would simply need to be equal to the winning vote differential; it would not matter for whom the fraudulent votes had been cast.
Wow, this establishes an incredibly perverse incentive. If a party believes that they will lose, they can engage in fraud in favor of the opposite party (e.g. burning boxes of ballots in safe districts), and spoil the vote. If the same party is already in power, it would appear that they could just keep playing this game, pardoning the offenders each time, and maintain control of the "interim" government indefinitely.
- whatshisface 5y ago>If the bill passes, the number of fraudulent votes required to do so would simply need to be equal to the winning vote differential; it would not matter for whom the fraudulent votes had been cast. >Wow, this establishes an incredibly perverse incentive. If a party believes that they will lose, they can engage in fraud in favor of the opposite party (e.g. burning boxes of ballots in safe districts), and spoil the vote. By this rule, they could have the election overturned by casting fraudulent votes for their own party.
- liquidise 5y agoI’m not sure. If Party A expects Party B to win by 1%, A can seek to frame B with fraud by creating 1% more vote for B, who now wins by roughly 2%, meaning the bill doesn’t apply as the margin is greater than the fraud. I don’t disagree with your assessment but I think the result is more complex. This becomes a statistical cat and mouse game, which again is a total distraction from the actual purpose of the voting process.
- klyrs 5y agoIndeed, that's a fair point. Perhaps it's not quite as easy as I initially imagined, but that doesn't really ease my concerns
- boomboomsubban 5y agoEven without that obvious long term power grab, intentionally spoiling an election and requiring a new one shifts the voter base. Compare voter turnout of presidential elections and midterms, any other election gets even less turnout. Plus, think of what one example of a "fraudulent election" would do to nationwide discourse.
- klyrs 5y ago> Plus, think of what one example of a "fraudulent election" would do to nationwide discourse. The Brooks Brothers Riot of 2000 did exactly that, and today's discourse is visibly impacted by its aftermath. It wasn't prosecuted, and Democrats complained about the potential illegitimacy of Bush's win for ages. When Trump called the 2020 election into question, Republicans pointed the finger at Democrats, essentially saying that turnabout is fair play.