4 ms·
>> If I'm reading conference papers, why would I worry about whether one of them is the product of review collusion? Well, because if there's no incentive to w
by YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago
>> If I'm reading conference papers, why would I worry about whether one of them is the product of review collusion?
Well, because if there's no incentive to write a good paper, very few good papers will ever get written and you'll waste your time reading crap papers.
I get what you say: if the process is random anyway, then what's the problem? But the process is not random: authors maximise their chances to publish their paper if they partake in a collusion ring. Partaking in a collusion ring diverts resources from writing a good paper, therefore the quality of published papers goes down the drain. The most important resource necessary to write a good paper of course is the motivation to not publish crap. If that goes, everything else follows.