5 ms·
France's Minitel service in 1983: online banking, eshopping, and B2B
- Duckpaddle2 15y agoWe actually had a Minitel service in Houston which in its way was a successful gaming platform. The social aspect never really took off.
- afiler 15y agoI had to look this up after you mentioned it. Looks like it was run by a company called US Videotel: http://www.digibarn.com/collections/systems/minitel-usa/index.html http://www.digibarn.com/collections/systems/minitel-usa/inde... I know the US also had some trials of teletext (text pages over broadcast TV) too, but I think that was even less successful than videotel.
- Nicolas___ 15y agoFunny thing is that today, despite the fact that everybody has a broadband connection, Minitel is still used by some people. Specifically for the 2 usages that made its success in the first place : yellow pages and adult chat. A few companies still make significant profit from this platform in 2011. And it's still profitable for France Telecom as well. Low tech works :)
- p4bl0 15y agoSadly, the service will be discontinued soon (june 2012). I don't use it but I find it cool to have an alternative network like this.
- johncoltrane 15y agoA number of very large logistics/hauling companies were still using it as a sort of extranet a couple of years ago.
- alx 15y agoI'm from Tetalab, a hackerspace in Toulouse, France, and we still use the minitel for some hacks with arduino: http://www.tetalab.org/images/tetalab/MSM.jpg http://www.tetalab.org/images/tetalab/MSM.jpg It's a neat interface, everybody here in France remember it from the 80's, and it quite easy to hack it. We should soon release an arduino lib for eveybody to hack it, but it'll be quite hard to find a minitel if you're not in France (nobody use it anymore, it's quite easy to find second-hand, but surely heavy to ship...)
- jgrahamc 15y agoC'est ou ça à Toulouse? J'habitais à Toulouse (l'hyper-centre) pendant trois ans.
- snippyhollow 15y agoJe pense que c'est ici http://www.mixart-myrys.org http://www.mixart-myrys.org // http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Mixart-Myrys+toulouse&hl=fr&ll=43.618128,1.421453&spn=0.007456,0.016544&sll=37.0625,-95.677068&sspn=65.390746,135.527344&z=17 http://maps.google.com/maps?q=Mixart-Myrys+toulouse&hl=f... :)
- kahawe 15y agoHow difficult would it be to make a proxy for it and make minitel accessible world wide? Do they bill you per minute?
- 15y ago
- abeppu 15y agoIt makes me a bit sad to realize that even I remember minitel, though I grew up with the internet, and not in France -- not because I'm into tech history, but because in 2002, that's how old my high-school French textbook and its helpful cultural asides were.
- mikecane 15y agoEveryone hailed Minitel in the 1980s. It was touted as an example of what gov't should do (these were also the days of Japan, Inc. kicking everyone's ass, also showing what gov't "should" do for industry). Yet along came the Black Swan of the Internet to slay it. Central planning never works.
- ugh 15y agoCentral planning is how humans organize cooperation. It’s everywhere. To argue that it never works is ridiculous on its face. Central planning probably gets harder the more humans want to cooperate and market mechanisms are very likely superior in those situations but that doesn’t mean that central planning doesn’t work.
- galactus 15y agoWasn't "the internet" created by the gouvernment too?
- jgrahamc 15y agoThe early days of Internet were funded by the US government but not in the same way as Minitel. The French government massively subsidized the deployment of Minitel by giving away millions of terminals (in exchange for not giving the subscriber the white pages on paper) and that helped launch it. But if you ignore the arguments about who funded what there are lots of aspects of Minitel that are interesting because it helped to kick off the wide use of smart cards, the underlying network was packet switched (X.25) and the servers handling Minitel were distributed through the network (so service providers ran their own services). It wouldn't view Minitel as a failure, however, just because it was replaced by the web. The French were years (probably 10) ahead of the rest of the world in terms of electronic communication and commerce. They had a large internal market online in the 1980s handling a huge amount of commerce.
- madflo 15y agoI may add that that after all, all the money granted for the Minitel program by the gouvernement has been recovered with taxes on Minitel minutes. I would consider the Minitel as a success of central planning. 20 years of e-economy and quite a lot of money moving from French citizen to French corporations or smaller businesses.
- MatthewPhillips 15y ago> Eventually the French Post Office hopes to turn a profit by charging companies for making their names available to Minitel subscribers. 30 years later and ISPs are trying to do this again.
- snippyhollow 15y agoOne of many fun facts: Xavier Niel (controversial CEO of Free, disruptive French ISP) made his first $ - sorry Francs - by selling adult chat on the Minitel.
- galactus 15y agoWhen I lived in France I loved Free. Best ISP I have ever used
- kahawe 15y agoWith prestel, BTX and MUPID there were quite a few prior technologies but to my knowledge, this only really took off like that in France due to substantial public funding. Prestel in UK died and BTX in Germany/Austria was but a novelty AFAIR. I have never seen BTX being widely used here but when I was on vacation in France, sure enough even the rest stops on the highway had a few minitel terminals you could pay for. And that was around 94 or 95 when the internet has already been heard of around here in Europe and the first ISPs started popping up.
- masklinn 15y agoThe Minitel was so entrenched long into the 90s it quite significantly hampered the original deployment of the 'net in France: * No need to register anywhere to use it (your identity was connected to your landline) * No maintenance or security issues * No compatibility issues (everything was pretty low-tech, but following strict standards) On the other hand, it had online payments, payments to sites (the national access provider charged based on access time depending on the service you connected to, and part of the money was funnelled to the service provider) and social media-based civil resistance (french university students coordinated strikes using Minitel as early as 1986). As a result the french population was not really taken aback by those capabilities in the interwebs, they were kinda used to them.
- rbanffy 15y agoI met my first wife on Minitel (Brazil had a several Minitel networks operated by its telcos that operated from the early 80s through mid 90s). I met my second wife at a party.
- arthur_debert 15y agoThat is definitely new to me. Granted, I was a child in the 80s but I never new that we had minitels down here. Live and learn.
- rbanffy 15y agoIt was called "videotexto". Telesp had, AFAIK, the largest install (in terms of pages and functions) but Telerj also had its own network. At that time, it was common for BBSs to support Minitel terminals connecting through 1200/75 (v.23, AFAIK) modems. http://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teletexto#No_Brasil http://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teletexto#No_Brasil
- zwieback 15y agoWe were one of the few households in Germany that had BTX, the German equivalent of Minitel. It wasn't free but pretty affordable and had some very useful services. Since banking in Germany never heavily relied on checks everyone was already using direct bank account transfers for payments as long as I can remember, certainly in the 80s. You filled out a standard machine readable slip and dropped it off at your bank and the transfer would happen immediately. I frequently used BTX to make payments for things I ordered and I seem to remember having a list of one-time use numbers to enter as a security measure. Must have been some kind of electronic signature. Germany was pretty anti-technology in those days. Instead of hailing early adopters we were frequently criticized as harbingers of a cold and inhumane new world order.
- rsynnott 15y agoThere was also an attempt to introduce a Minitel system here in Ireland. It was ridiculously badly-timed; by the time it was actually up and running, things like Compuserve were around and the first ISPs were only a couple of years away.
- antirez 15y agoI remember that in Italy there were a lot of minitels and what was impressive was that there were minitel pages where you could buy services, it was pretty impressive and the "chat" page was full of people. I remember I was a bit shocked when a few years later no body was using it anymore... I wonder why it failed even before the internet started to be widely used.