3 ms·
UN doc: military drones may have autonomously ‘hunted down’ and attacked troops [pdf]
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoPage 7 of the linked pdf report: > Logistics convoys and retreating HAF were subsequently hunted down and remotely engaged by the unmanned combat aerial vehicles or the lethal autonomous weapons systems such as the STM Kargu-2 (see annex 30) and other loitering munitions. The lethal autonomous weapons systems were programmed to attack targets without requiring data connectivity between the operator and the munition: in effect, a true “fire, forget and find” capability. The unmanned combat aerial vehicles and the small drone intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance capability of HAF were neutralized by electronic jamming from the Koral electronic warfare system.47
- aero-glide2 5y agoDon't Air-to-Air missiles already do this? (fire and forget)
- axiosgunnar 5y agoWhat does fire and forget even mean? That the missile follows its target automatically and you dont have to think about it anymore? Interesting, then the only difference between an „autonomous killer drone“ supposedly uncovered by the UN and a plain and simple fight jet missile is...the duration of the flight of the drone vs the missile? But then perhaps a missile like an ICBM would take longer than the drone here took? So perhaps even that differentiator does not work.
- hnnnnnnng 5y agoFire and forget means it requires no more input/information from whatever fired it. The benefit is that the platform that launched it is free to do other things.
- jamra 5y agoPerhaps a notable difference would be the civilians that could come into proximity of the target from the point of deploying to the point of executing.
- hnnnnnnng 5y agoBeyond visual range engagements require powerful radar that cannot fit in the missile itself. The missile can only navigate the last leg of it's journey without relying on external information.
- mft_ 5y agoI’m a million miles from this area, so I’m interested: [why] is a machine killing people more immoral than people killing people?
- 1cvmask 5y agoExactly. We never needed machines before to kill each other or commit genocides or kill babies. We even vote murderers into office.
- truth_ 5y agoWe use "machines" to kill people. Guns, grenades, flamethrowers are all machines much more advanced than their predecessors. But people batted their eyes on the advent of these weapons. People are going to bat eyes in the advent of these weapons as well. That is not going to stop Pentagon, China, or Russia from using these weapons. One issue could be that they are not as reliable as target seekers as they are good as target destroyers. And plenty of mistakes have been committed by humans in charge. Whether autonomous weapons system will be better than seeking and killing enemy combatants rather than innocent people is something to observe. Right now, autonomous systems are very very unreliable at this.
- juanani 5y agoSo because people kill people, machines should be allowed to kill people? not even logical, I can see an argument being valid as in why shouldn't machines kill other machines. why do you think machines should be allowed to kill people?
- rsj_hn 5y agoWhy do you think they shouldn't be allowed? We have been using machines to kill for a very long time, and this is the first I'm hearing of someone having an ethical problem with the fact that the killing is not done with bare hands. There may be ethical questions in war, but I don't see why the mechanisms should matter. Perhaps it should but you haven't even come close to making that case.
- mft_ 5y ago