4 ms·
The part of this that I think is most interesting is that the high level flow of the article goes from "some dude doesn't wash his hands" to "tobacco companies
by roenxi 5y ago
The part of this that I think is most interesting is that the high level flow of the article goes from "some dude doesn't wash his hands" to "tobacco companies were shady about trying to sell tobacco", a brief segue into "modern monkey science is better than older monkey science" and then ... rather suddenly ... "How can we intervene in social networks to direct people toward truth and facts?".
There are really bad ideas in this article. These systems won't be used to target obviously wrong information. It'll be used to target borderline true information that turns out to be right in hindsight. What they are suggesting at the end of this is a system that will be co-opted by groups like tobacco companies to suppress the truth.
People who want "all social media sites ... employing teams to fight active misinformation and disinformation" are much more dangerous than misinformation. They are creating systematic weak points for the truth to be suppressed, and relying on the fact that surely there are now powerful or motivated bad actors who will corrupt their beautiful but delicate system!
I spent 2020 watching people with PHDs in medical fields tying themselves in knots to avoid being censored by YouTube - and saying things that turned out to be true. I'd bet not a single person working for the censors had a PHD. There is madness somewhere here.
- seattle_spring 5y ago> I spent 2020 watching people with PHDs in medical fields tying themselves in knots to avoid being censored by YouTube - and saying things that turned out to be true Which sorts of things did they want to say?
- colejohnson66 5y agoProbably anything related to COVID. My understanding is that early on, YouTube was majorly aggressive on COVID misinformation to the point of harming creators.
- roenxi 5y agoMy favourite was back in February or March when the official guidance was "no masks" and the consensus was "that probably isn't right". Plus I'd like to be getting uncensored reporting on this vaccine blood clotting issue that the AstraZenica vaccine has. I didn't hear anything until it went from "vaccines are perfectly safe" to suspended [2] in multiple countries for safety concerns. Honest discussion about the vaccine side effects and safety reporting systems are exactly the sort of thing YouTube would censor, so they won't talk about it freely. Also from memory and a Google search [0, 1] to confirm, some countries like India still suggest Hydroxycloroquine. I'd like to hear some small time experts discussing why that is vs how much of the negative response was because Trump used the word in a sentence. The fact check in particular is silent on why the recommendation is there. If I can't listen to PHDs, why should I be listening to news pundits on this stuff? [0] https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/RevisedguidelinesforHomeIsolationofmildasymptomaticCOVID19cases.pdf https://www.mohfw.gov.in/pdf/RevisedguidelinesforHomeIsolati... [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/05/21/fact-check-india-covid-19-cases-hydroxychloroquine-not-related/5173021001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/05/21/fac... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford-AstraZeneca_COVID-19_vaccine#Suspensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford-AstraZeneca_COVID-19_va...
- devwastaken 5y agoFor every PhD saying something accurate there's hundreds of far more popular disinformation sources that are backed by superstition and sometimes funded by superstitious conspiracy peddlers, and sometimes by cold war enemies. Social media is by it's nature manipulatable, those with the bots and the money win. Not to mention plenty of people with phds are looking to make that Dr.Oz money or just being a plain superstitious human being that doesn't care about the truth.
- roenxi 5y agoYeah, and I think everyone in the debate agrees on that. But given that, why is there a call to set up teams of censors who have no qualifications and come from an essentially unknown culture? It is foreseeable that the YouTube/Twitter/Facebook censorship teams will be run by someone with ties to high level people in the Democratic or Republican party. Either of those is bad. Or maybe even quiet ties to foreign governments. If not them, it'll be people who are "ex"-big tobacco or Fox News/CNN types or ... I mean, the list gets long very quickly. And by "foreseeable" I don't mean possible, I mean likely to the point of certainty. The payoffs are massive for corrupting these single points of failure and there are a lot of people out there who will try. And the outcome of all of this is people with suspect credentials shutting down conversation or ideas from actual experts in the field. This article is advocating bad ideas. I'll accept that they may be inevitable, but it is going to be worse than it is now. We'll be protected from stuff that is (1) harmless or (2) true but politically threatening to whoever controls social media.