5 ms·
"This all essentially boils down to “freedom.”" But school is about creating obedient subjects so that the government can maintain status quo. I don't see them
by giantg2 5y ago
"This all essentially boils down to “freedom.”"
But school is about creating obedient subjects so that the government can maintain status quo. I don't see them promoting anything that is radically different which has the potential to undermine the thought processes that support out institutions.
- kiba 5y agoOk. Where is the evidence that schools are created to create obedient subjects for governments to maintain status quo?
- pharmakom 5y agoThe UK government uses public schools to push their preferred narrative around British history and “Britishness”. However, I think the real reason for schools is that the government sees a return on investment via taxation of a higher skilled workforce.
- oblio 5y agoSchools kind of are for that, but it's not actually a bad thing despite the negative framing. The goal of the public school system is to create active, disciplined, stable, civilized citizens with strong bonds for each other despite natural tribal tendencies.
- giantg2 5y agoSeems like they are failing then. A substantial majority of people do not understand thw way the government is supposed to work nor their parts in it. https://woodrow.org/news/national-survey-finds-just-1-in-3-americans-would-pass-citizenship-test/ https://woodrow.org/news/national-survey-finds-just-1-in-3-a...
- oblio 5y agoIt is working. Americans generally feel American, Chinese feel Chinese, Romanians feel Romanian. That's the great end product of school education up to about 14-18 years.
- giantg2 5y agoI meant in the active category. Just look at stuff like voter turnout. How many people write their representatives, or read the actual text of a bill (usually easier at local and state level single the federal ones tend to be much longer), or send a comment to an agency about a proposed regulation change? Pretty often I hear people say things that are wrong about their rights. How can we demand and protect our rights if people don't even know what they are? Even if you read the constitution, the actual implementation is greatly different and even contrary to the text.
- oblio 5y agoActive doesn't only mean politically active. I actually meant it more in the "economically" active. Free, public schooling has lifted many, many people out of poverty and into the middle classes. Most people aren't political. I don't think there's any way to change that, they just don't care.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't just mean politically. There are civic duties that are apolitical. Take jury duty for example. Many people make up excuses to get out of it. Being an informed voter, regardless of party, is a civic duty. "Free, public schooling has lifted many, many people out of poverty and into the middle classes." Has it though? Maybe historically (generations ago). The poverty rate has been largely stagnate for the past 30 years at about 13% give or take. Even 50 years ago it was about 19%. Desegregation and safety net programs arguably played a bigger role in that improvement. There are some public high schools that have abysmal graduation rates and college readiness rates in the single digits.
- 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoHere's some good background. https://fee.org/articles/the-origins-of-the-public-school/ https://fee.org/articles/the-origins-of-the-public-school/
- NateEag 5y agoJohn Taylor Gatto was an award-winning public school teacher who argued roughly that. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor_Gatto https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor_Gatto
- kiba 5y agoHe isn't an historian.
- daenz 5y agoYou didn't ask for a historian, you asked for evidence.
- NateEag 5y agoHistorians are the only sources you'd accept for evidence? I guess that's your prerogative, but I'm not going to put in any further effort to help you find the evidence you asked for. FYI, I don't necessarily agree with Gatto, but he makes the strongest case I've seen for the position you're arguing against. You should start with him if you want to refute it.
- nate_meurer 5y agoAnecdotally, I know a lot of teachers, and not a one of them is the least bit interested in creating minions subservient to the state.
- LordDragonfang 5y agoI know a lot of teachers as well, and almost all of them bemoan how the curriculum they're forced to teach to is structured - especially those in the social sciences. It's by and large not the teachers that are the problem with schools, it's the system itself.
- giantg2 5y agoThen why all the fighting over politically based things covered in many schools, like CSE, anything religious, critical race theory, guns, etc? Most schools and teachers are looking for answers that fit their own ideas or preferences and grade outside-the-box answers as wrong, even when there's merit to them. There are people on both sides of the political spectrum that believe that specific topics should not be covered because it amounts to indoctrination, even if the teachers are attempting to cover in a nonindoctrinaring way.
- marksbrown 5y agoSchool is the advertising agency which makes you believe that you need the society as it is. Ivan illich