3 ms·
that was a pretty long comment, with a lot of points to follow.
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
that was a pretty long comment, with a lot of points to follow.
- LegitShady 5y agobut you can find the main point in 3 seconds - it's in the second line, on it's own, with a symbol beside it. Then I get into the story. You can choose to follow along or not afterward - you've gotten the most important point right away.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoOk, that symbol though - the > is generally used as a quote symbol in HN, so of course I was confused as to what was being quoted. on edit: by quote symbol I mean this is the point that someone else in the parent comment or the article made that I am going to respond to in my following bit of text.
- LegitShady 5y agoI think it's actually a carry over from reddit, where it activates the quote, while here on hacker news it does nothing. It's just a symbol.
- dragonwriter 5y agoIt’s a carryover from long established internet (plaintext email, Usenet, etc.) convention, which is where reddit (and lots of other forums) got it, too.
- LegitShady 5y agomost people on the internet have never used plain text email, or usenet. A fair chunk of them have used reddit, where it actually does something. So I guess it's just not that important to me, overall, to use a convention that few people have ever used. If HN had a basic quote function it wouldn't matter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- havelhovel 5y ago> So I guess it's just not that important to me, overall, to use a convention that few people have ever used. My favorite writing tip is knowing one’s audience. (:
- LegitShady 5y agoMy audience is not curmudgeons who require I use their quote convention that doesn't actually do anything, because they're unlikely to learn anything from anyone anyways, since they're nitpicking symbology.
- jlokier 5y agoIntriguing. I have never used Reddit except as a search result. The ">" is ubiquitous in email, usenet, Markdown, Github and Discord, which are more familiar. It seems to be a widely used convention here on HN as well, even though HN software doesn't highlight it. It's baked into a lot of modern software due to long-standing convention for about half a century. Nowadays that software includes anything taking input with a vague similarity to Markdown. There's a lot of that about.
- LegitShady 5y agoIt's stupid. If HN implemented a quote feature, it would mean something. if I preceded every quote with a bold pipe | for each line of the quote it would be more noticeable, but of course HN doesn't provide a WYIWYG editor so you never know when a new line starts. It's just a first line visual indicator here. Consider me your quote symbol iconoclast. There's no reason for > to mean quote in a system that doesn't implement quotes. It's just a cultural construct being followed 'because thats how it was'.
- antonvs 5y ago> It's just a cultural construct That's the point. It doesn't have to "do anything" in software or be "implemented" to be useful - it has shared meaning in people's minds. You're reminding me of the small child who receives a non-electronic action figure for Christmas and immediately asks, "but what does it do?"