5 ms·
This assumes that the non-breadwinner did not work. In the vast majority, the second party, almost always a wife, was busy homemaking -- toiling from sunup to
by klyrs 5y ago
This assumes that the non-breadwinner did not work. In the vast majority, the second party, almost always a wife, was busy homemaking -- toiling from sunup to sundown tending children, making labor-intensive meals, cleaning, doing laundry, making clothes, growing and preserving food, etc. Did they get paid for their 12-hour workday? No. They significantly enabled the breadwinner to specialize in his field, but only he is seen as contributing to the economy.
Today, we've got machines to do the dishes and the laundry, refrigeration, and foreign slaves / wage-slaves to make our clothes and crops. Homemaking is less labor intensive today, and what could be more leisure time has been replaced with two-income houses.
And, for example, my great grandma was both a housewife and she had a job at a sweatshop. The single-income household wasn't really an option for the poor in the 40s, and I suspect that it's only been broadly available to the upper class.
- 988747 5y agoToday women have jobs so that they could pay for cleaning, doing laundry or for daycare for their children. Financially it cancels itself out, but women get just as little time with their own children as men.
- azinman2 5y agoAs if the only thing women want in life is to mother? Or that men never want to father given that women now can have a career that isn’t only low level?
- gsich 5y agoMost people don't have a "career". With that I assume that you want to become management or CEO. Everything else is just normal work. In that sense, exchanging motherly duties with meaningless work is not worth it.
- midasuni 5y agoBeing a teacher is a career. Being a doctor. Being a lawyer. Going into management and other paper pushing is pointless work sure, but many careers are very valuable and build upon skills and experience in that job with profession in that job as much as you want.
- gsich 5y agoSo your "career" is just "work" or "job". Which is fine, because everyone has a career then, even if you stay at home for your children.
- azinman2 5y agoI have a good friend who is an architect, which is neither CEO or management, who wants to be able to express her trade but has very mixed feelings about the need to also mother. Even if retail or whatnot, having an identity outside of the home to give you self worth isn’t exactly unique to C-level execs. I think it’s quite patronizing to assume that’s the only route to self-actualization.
- gsich 5y agoI don't know why people think that being a mother is somewhat bad.
- azinman2 5y agoPerhaps I worded that wrong. When I said mixed feelings about the need to mother, I mean the pull where society says she must choose between career and mothering, and that it’s selfish for her to choose more time working. Yet this is of course never done for the husband who is assumed to by default be the one that can and should choose work over fathering. The larger point being that 2 parents working to cover child care costs seems impractical from a viewpoint that looks at that net, but that would exclude the fact that many people define identity, societal productivity, fulfillment and even enjoyment from their jobs outside the home. It’s also means that you can continue advancing in your career so that when you don’t need full time child care you’re in a stronger position. Many women who leave work for years to parent have a very hard time getting hired.
- midasuni 5y agoThe point is rather than having 2 parents working 5 days a week between them, it’s 2 parents working 10 days a week (and maybe more) They need to do this because the house that was affordable on one salary in the 80s now requires 2 salaries and childcare Not everyone is like that, but I had to explain why we didn’t have childcare costs when we took a mortgage put last week (I work as in the original point - I work from home, I take the kids to school for 0830 and pick them up at 1530, in between I do things like the dishwasher (while boiling the kettle or making lunch) and do what I deem enough hours to fulfil the goals of my department.
- lliamander 5y agoThe parent point assumed nothing of the kind. For the point of this analysis, it doesn't matter whether the non-breadwinner was busy homemaking, skydiving, or collecting stamps. The point is that they didn't need to trade their labor for money, and now they do.
- klyrs 5y agoNo, you and OC are equating labor with leisure. Women were treated as property until very recently in history, and a married man was at significant advantage to an unmarried man. Some women of the time had a choice: to enrol in a relationship with a man and toil for his household, or to toil for a paltry income; many needed to do both. Skydiving and stamp collecting were only options for the independently wealthy
- xupybd 5y agoI don't think women were treated as property by the vast majority.
- klyrs 5y agoLegally speaking, coverture laws stuck around until the 1960s. There was certainly a gradient both de jure and de facto, in time and in space, but my grandpas certainly beat my grandmas like they were property. One wouldn't stand that crap, and left his ass. The other was just subservient. I have cousins whose husbands won't allow them to learn how to drive, and only let them spend money on groceries. De jure, they could leave at any time. De facto, they're treated as sub-human. Today.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tobesure 5y ago>toiling from sunup to sundown tending children, making labor-intensive meals, cleaning, doing laundry, making clothes, growing and preserving food, etc. You are vastly overestimating the relative contributions of females. The times you're describing had men giving their bodies to dangerous labor and also working longer than modern hours. >Did they get paid for their 12-hour workday? Yes, they received dividends with respect to the centers of their lives, children. This is a major point that supporters of workforce gender parity simply do not understand, because the modern feminist movement all but destroyed the cultural sanctity of the family unit in a misguided quest for faux-equality. Suddenly being a housewives is menial and subservient and all women should strive for careers. In effect we doubled the workforce and made dual income a requirement for the middle class. >but only he is seen as contributing to the economy. Only with a deliberately uncharitable interpretation. This interpretation is further biased by the fact that women tending to family do not need to deal with the stresses of employment, or being forced to work on someone else's schedule and at someone else's pace. Nevermind the natural sexual dimorphism with respect to child rearing which was the ultimate source of this critical specialization, not some evil patriarchal plot to keep women oppressed.