3 ms·
You seriously think that hospitals charge $10 per aspirin because the upper middle classes are using more of it these days rather than because the upper upper c
by pydry 5y ago
You seriously think that hospitals charge $10 per aspirin because the upper middle classes are using more of it these days rather than because the upper upper classes are running a racket?
- rayiner 5y agoHospital operating margins are in the single digits: https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/hospital-margins-continue-fall-amid-rising-expenses https://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/hospital-margins-.... Almost all of that $10 aspirin goes to paying doctors, administrators, nurses, rent, etc. All of those are in short supply and demand continues to grow. Why would you reflexively assume “the upper upper class” is involved? Billionaires tend to make things cheaper for consumers while gutting the upper class below them. Amazon wipes out owners of regional or local retail chains, but makes things cheaper for consumers. (That’s a big part of why the 0.01% is pulling away from the 1%. It’a billionaires eating the lunch of millionaires.) Contrast areas like education, where there are no “upper upper class” making profits. Tuitions continue to skyrocket due to growing expenses—in salaries, physical plant, etc. It’s a racket, but it’s a racket run by the upper middle class.
- sudosysgen 5y agoHospital operating margins are in the single digits, so what? That doesn't mean that less than 10% of the price of that aspirin goes to profit. How much of that rent is profit? How much of the drugs being used goes to profit, and how much of the equipment and material of that drug goes to profit, and so on. If you want to cite a meaningful margin number, use the entire vertical. You can't limit yourself to a single level in the value chain and say that the overall margins are low. There are definitely upper upper classes making profits in education. "Physical plant" means money going to RE conglomerates. Beyond that the slew of education industry providers seems to make an EBITDA margin on average of more than 10% : https://csimarket.com/Industry/industry_Profitability_Ratios.php?ind=903 https://csimarket.com/Industry/industry_Profitability_Ratios...
- tptacek 5y agoIt's all one system. If you supplied aspirin at cost+10%, other prices would swing wildly to offset the change. Ultimately, the real expense in health care is health care professionals delivering health care services, and no matter what you think aspirin should cost, the hospital won't run at a deficit; some combination of line-items on your bill is going to add up to the cost of all the professionals delivering the work. It's not good that "hospital aspirin" has a price disconnected with the economics of aspirin. But it's a sideshow issue. You can't make health care cost effective for consumers by fixing the aspirin problems.
- pydry 5y ago>Hospital operating margins are in the single digits Of course. And Star Wars made a loss: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110912/13500315912/hollywood-accounting-darth-vader-not-getting-paid-because-return-jedi-still-isnt-profitable.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110912/13500315912/holly... >Why would you reflexively assume “the upper upper class” is involved? Because at the same time that their wealth is climbing stratospherically, healthcare costs are also rising stratospherically and there has been significant market consolidation. Somebody's making bank. >In crude terms, the health-care labyrinth comprises six layers, each involving the state, mutual organisations and private firms. People and employers pay insurance companies, which pay opaque aggregators known as pharmacy-benefit managers and preferred provider organisers. They in turn pay doctors, hospitals and pharmacies, which in turn pay wholesalers, who pay the manufacturers of equipment and drugs. Some conglomerates span several layers. For example on March 8th Cigna, an insurance firm, bid $67bn for Express Scripts, a benefit manager. A system of rebates means money flows in both directions so that the real price of products and services (net of rebates) is obscured. https://archive.is/Qh8ev#selection-745.0-745.683 https://archive.is/Qh8ev#selection-745.0-745.683 Did you think the hospital is the only party that could make a profit out of your suffering?