3 ms·
Yeah well that cultural revolution got taken over fairly quickly & subverted, turned into a stunning anti-revolutionary authoritarianism & wiped from the mind o
by rektide 5y ago
Yeah well that cultural revolution got taken over fairly quickly & subverted, turned into a stunning anti-revolutionary authoritarianism & wiped from the mind of the people. I dont think you'll see American's cultural revolutionary hopes subverted anywhere so quickly, nor do I think we'll see them given ability to take root so strongly in the first place. This article focuses only on the revolutionary part, but ignores so much of what happened after, how quickly things re-set, changed back, ignores how anti-revolutionary China became & how harshly & quickly the country snapped back.
There's a lot of decent history of China, with a surprisingly good variety of footage & audio mixed in, in Adam Curtis's recent (fantastic) Can't Get You Out Of My Head[1]. It's possibly one of the best tellings of the past ~70 years that's out there. It does such an incredible job describing how power gels, how it forms & defends it's turf. The story of China's revolution & it's rapid counter-revolutionary burying of that past is a huge theme through the series, especially as it relates to the industrial developments of the rest of the world.
The article here isn't much into all that. It's harping a lot on the very narrow window of revolutionary tumult. And throwing mud at those who would try to improve things, those who ask for change. It's a pitch for stability, for order, for respecting the 1% and 0.1% whatever the situation. It does detail the dehumanization, shows a rampant out of control anti-elite behavioralism, but ignores the deep iniquities & injustices suffered in America & instead compares the current activist protestors to the brutal violent deeply demeaning revolutionary politics, which seems completely batshit out of line insane. It's filled with Fear Uncertainty & Doubt, ultra-conservatism, messages like "Mobs have a logic of their own," meant to let the audience see those asking not to be the victims of endless police brutality as nothing more than a bunch of insurrectionist out of control threats.
I really really really dislike the gist of this article, in almost every way. I think there are probably some lessons, some things we could learn. But this feels like an incredibly sloppy onsided ultra-biased article, that links radically radically different situations through extremely tenuous connections. I don't like the axe this dude is grinding, and I don't think his so called lessons apply.
[1] https://thoughtmaybe.com/cant-get-you-out-of-my-head/ https://thoughtmaybe.com/cant-get-you-out-of-my-head/