24 ms·
We don't need judges to be politicians, because we have politicians. We don't need them to be kings - we got rid of kings for very good reasons. We need judge
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
We don't need judges to be politicians, because we have politicians. We don't need them to be kings - we got rid of kings for very good reasons.
We need judges to be the referees, not just another set of players in the game.
- thisiswater 5y agoTo compare judges to kings in this case is so absurd as to barely be worth refuting. The court is working within within a legal framework, not wielding supreme executive power granted by divine right and inherited through a dynasty.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoBut in the post I replied to, Applejinx made exactly that comparison. So don't blame me...
- wrycoder 5y agoThey wield supreme judicial power. The legislative body can then try pass laws to more precisely define the activities involved. The judiciary can then declare those new laws to be unconstitutional. That is an active judiciary. It is be deplored. The judiciary in the US is supposed to be the weakest branch of three. The EU is an example of what happens when it's the strongest.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe ultimate backstop to this is constitutional amendments (in the cases where the issue is actually Constitutional... In the case of, for example, Oracle v Google, the courts declared APIs were copyrightable as a matter of law, which could be altered by legislation).
- shkkmo 5y agoMany Judges in the USA are elected... 39 out of 50 states elect some of their judges.
- atoav 5y agoJudges interpret and use the law. Yet if you have a constitutional law that says every citizen has to treated with dignity this might mean something entirely different in the year 1800 than it does in 1950, 1990 or 2021. It might include/exclude different people, it might have practically no impact or a lot of impact etc. Justices can interpret laws in a way that makes sense for the time and surrounding they live in. And they have to do it as long as the law is not 100% clearly written (which it isn't usually)