3 ms·
The judiciary isn't making laws; it's pointing out the ramifications of existing laws and precedent. The judiciary would love the legislature to be in front of
by anigbrowl 5y ago
The judiciary isn't making laws; it's pointing out the ramifications of existing laws and precedent. The judiciary would love the legislature to be in front of such questions, but they can't force another branch of government to legislate, nor is there any legal route for the populace to do so other than voting and hoping politicians will deliver on non-binding commitments.
- hcurtiss 5y agoBut that's precisely how it's supposed to work. That there is not (yet) sufficient political will to adopt these policies by statute does not in any way create a duty for the judiciary to act. Congress makes the laws. It's the judiciary's job to interpret them. At least so far, there is no law (in the US) with a generic obligation to protect future generations from environmental harm. I question how such a law could even work given that a great deal of human activity permanently alters the natural environment.
- lazyasciiart 5y agoBut we're not talking about the US judiciary.
- hcurtiss 5y agoThese comments are responding to my original, which was directed to the US judiciary. I understand the linked article is not, but given the large US readership on HN, discussion of how the US works strikes me as germane.