3 ms·
I think that's a big chunk of it. It explains a question that's been nagging me: if we've been pumping money into the economy for over a decade, why isn't there
by jfengel 5y ago
I think that's a big chunk of it. It explains a question that's been nagging me: if we've been pumping money into the economy for over a decade, why isn't there inflation?
Answer: there is, it's just asset inflation, not consumer inflation.
Still, if real estate is one of those assets, that should have filtered down to the consumer level. Is it isolated away from most consumer real estate? Or has the real estate fraction of CPI actually been rising while something else is falling to compensate? (The latter should be easily testable, but I don't have time at the moment.)
- medium_burrito 5y agoI think the reason it hasn't hit consumers more is because most consumers cannot afford assets. The best analogy I can make is Ecuador, which although one of the poorest countries in SA has very high prices on average. It was explained to me that this is because government salaries are pegged to a certain rate, and that basically forms the middle class. All the poor cannot buy stuff anyway, so the high prices don't really matter in that sense.
- endymi0n 5y agoSo my pet theory is: All conventional wisdom on inflation deals with the assumption that all money is equal. But we've come into an unprecedented situation where a lower and lower share of overall money is actually used in transit instead of being parked. You don't really notice all that invisible money, because in practice, inflation is really only tangible on the circulating part, that's why the overall supply increase doesn't _feel_ like inflation. That circulating part of money already has shrunk further and further, now probably down to single digit percents. What will happen if a big fish actually tries to cash in a large chunk of that invisible money for goods and services? No clue. We're in completely uncharted territory.
- N1H1L 5y agoEconomics does take that into account. Look up velocity of money. One of the easiest ways to increase money velocity is to have progressive taxation BTW
- pydry 5y agoWhy would there be a major cash in event? If history is any guide this wealth will be kept locked up and passed down to the next generation in perpetuity. And so on and so on, until a war destroys the capital base, kicking off a new cycle, or a revolution takes place (exceedingly unlikely, despite how much people talk about it). People talk about this level of wealth inequality as if it's unusual and destabilizing, but the gini coefficient of the Roman empire was frequently higher and it lasted for well over a thousand years. Indeed, I think it's quite likely that we're simply nearing the end of an anomalous period of history starting with WW2 where movement between social classes was unrestricted.
- Gibbon1 5y agoI saw saw a chart that showed the change in prices of stocks, bonds, real estate, consumer goods, and wages over ten years. What economists call inflation, wage and price inflation, was something like 13-17% total over 10 years. Where everything else more than doubled. We get gaslighted to only think about the wage and price inflation year over year rate. But not the the total relative change in prices over time. The latter is the important part.
- heterodoxxed 5y agoOne aspect I'm fascinated with is the way that consumer goods are continually dropping in price offsets the increase in necessities. We get a supercomputer in our pocket for $40 a month, but rent has ballooned. We can have hundreds of video games for free but we'll never own a home. And so on. We all get wikipedia for free, but a college degree is painfully expensive in a world that doesn't let you apply for jobs on the strengths of self-education. As someone on here said years ago, "I love my iphone but I worry about health insurance." What good is cheap frivolities if the necessary building blocks of life are skyrocketing.
- Gibbon1 5y agoMy dad's crusty friends refer to that as deflation for things you want, inflation for things you need. Also official reasoning about housing costs ignores that there are huge variations in that prices people have to pay to house themselves. The focus on average market rates hides the reality on the ground.
- jfengel 5y agoI wouldn't call it "gaslighting". People need to eat, wear clothes, have a place to stay, etc., which is the kind of thing measured by price inflation. If that stuff is relatively stable then it doesn't matter nearly as much if stocks and bonds go up. That's a concern primarily to wealthier people who already have assets, and for them, the increases are double-edged swords. Them that has, gets. Them that doesn't -- i.e. young but upwardly mobile people -- are forced to play that high-risk game. The genuinely poor weren't playing that game to begin with, and could never retire, so they were always out of luck. The only thing they have going for them is social security, i.e. wealth transfer. It's not much, but the alternative would be absolute poverty, which is what it looked like in the early 20th century. I'm more concerned about them then about whether the wealthy stay wealthy, or even whether the young and upwardly-mobile can get assets.
- runawaybottle 5y agoYou are asking the same question the Bank of Japan has been asking for a long time now. Pretty sure Japan had negative inflation just this last year, and they are right there with us in terms of making the money printer go brrrrr.