5 ms·
Facebook should never have stifled the debate about Covid’s origins
- Pet_Ant 5y agoThe ability the stifle conversation will always end up being applied in the wrong situations and it’s better to do nothing at all then to get it wrong.
- dado3212 5y agoDidn’t fact checkers also reverse their opinions, which primarily backs FBs misinformation enforcement? I have a hard time personally squaring my desire to limit misinformation spread on social media (Holocaust denial, etc) with my lack of desire for SM platforms to become truth deciders. This feels like a normal occurrence of the system working mostly correctly: experts widely discount the lab leak theory and FB decreases the spread of perceived medical misinformation, experts reverse that opinion and FB stops enforcement.
- bananabiscuit 5y agoDiscounting the lab leak theory always seemed very politically motivated to me (although I am not sure exactly what the motive was). It always seemed very suspicious that a definitive conclusion about the origin was drawn so quickly despite us barely knowing anything else about the virus. It also seemed incredibly suspicious that there was such a large effort to repress anyone who questioned the origin. The cherry of irony on top is how considering all possible theories of origin was labeled “science denial”, but appealing to authority with questionable motives was “trusting the science”.
- andromeduck 5y agoThe solution is to have a much higher evidentiary threshold.
- anothermoron 5y agohttps://babylonbee.com/news/snopes-introduces-new-rating-false-for-now https://babylonbee.com/news/snopes-introduces-new-rating-fal...
- helen___keller 5y agoI dunno, someone I know got into a particular conspiracy site where the "theory" snowballed into "covid was bioengineered by china, and once everyone gets vaccinated they'll release a second engineered virus that kills vaccinated people due to Antibody Dependent Enhancement, therefor it's safer for me to not get vaccinated and just stay indoors for the next 2-4 years instead" Imagine if that kind of thing went mainstream before the vaccine rollout.
- dqpb 5y agoIs that even technically feasible?
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoIn a fantasy world where the virus communicates over 5G, anything is possible...
- dude187 5y agoYou don't need to censor free and open discourse to prevent something like that from being a mainstream view.
- vfclists 5y agoMore deflection from the not so mainstream media outlets who pretend not to be aligned with the MSM. The next "scandal" is the issue of thousands of people dying needlessly because the Govt, FDA and NIH claimed that there were no outpatient treatments available for Covid and drugs like Ivermectin and Hydroxychloroquine were ineffective. The infamous "stay at home until Covid begins to kill you" scandal.
- didibus 5y agoI think the issue is people's belief system kicks in. Even now, people read this probably think: I knew it was from the lab! Well no, we don't know where it's from yet. I personally felt the messaging had always been that we don't know the origin clearly but there are a few possibilities, a lab leak being one, wet markets another, and bats a third. I could see though how there could have been a "conspiracy" minded movement who'd start to hold strong beliefs of a lab leak and then mix that in with anti-asian racism and such. Then it becomes political, and probably people start posting things that make it sound like it is for sure a lab leak, and all that. As an example, in more Chinese driven countries, I had read, there are lots of theories about how the virus is American made from a lab at the Maryland military base. Basically all these conversations are about "pointing fingers" and "pushing blame". It's very political, and the truth will be hard to come out. Personally I think best not to care where it's from, we still have to deal with it none the less.
- dqpb 5y agoWhen there are two options, and one seems a little more obvious, but then there is a seemingly coordinated stigmatization of that option and undue consensus on the other option, then that starts to feel like a pretty strong data point in its own right.
- didibus 5y agoYes, it is suspicious not to let an independent committee audit the lab, and to disallow access to all information related to it. I'm not going to deny that. It also doesn't make it a cold hard proof. But I do know that pissing of China at the start of a pandemic isn't a good way to help the world mitigate the pandemic either. You need international collaboration and for everyone to work together and relay what they learn of the virus and its transmission and all that. At my work, we have policies similar where in the case of a production event, you don't blame the dev who released the bad code or made the faulty change, because doing so creates an atmosphere that doesn't help with root causing and fixing the issue.
- toomuchredbull 5y agoIt's probably best if lay people focused on their families and their work and their general well being, however, I don't know if the best idea is to suppress information, particularly information that is then revealed to be true. It creates a massive distrust in our governing institutions. For instance, I plainly don't trust any of our tech companies at all, nor the government, nor the media with the truth about basically anything. They have all shown they are incapable throughout this pandemic. Not sure having that level of societal disfunction allows people to focus on their families, their jobs, and their general well being.
- andromeduck 5y agoIMO Google should not try to become an arbiter of truth either. Nothing good can come from it. Provide context yes, reflect the discourse yes, perhaps even bias to academics & take a clearly marked official opinion/positio, but never ever ever censor much do so when there is no overwhelming long standing consensus.
- 908B64B197 5y agoCould Facebook benefit from helping the Chinese regime save face? [0] Seems their founder has some double allegiances and a financial incentive to please the regime. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S20BoxH8W9g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S20BoxH8W9g
- sunstone 5y agoFacebook is just a spout of propaganda paid for by the highest bidder and targeting the most vulnerable and gullible. The brain cancer of civil society.