4 ms·
God no. No one handles XML namespaces well. They are an absolute nightmare to deal with in almost every language. We already have this in JSON: add a hashmap k
by XorNot 5y ago
God no. No one handles XML namespaces well. They are an absolute nightmare to deal with in almost every language.
We already have this in JSON: add a hashmap key with a prefix. It's at least as robust provided tools do the sensible thing and ignore keys they don't care about. But as with XML, sometimes, they don't, or do, or something.
- skissane 5y ago> add a hashmap key with a prefix Maybe I'm paranoid, but I worry someone else will pick the same prefix as me. If you make the prefix something like a domain name, e.g example.com:myExtension, nobody else is going to use the same prefix assuming you own example.com. That avoids the risk, but it can be a lot of typing. Whereas, if the prefix is something short and obviously meaningful (e.g "doc:"), there is a risk someone else will use the same prefix in a conflicting way. What I liked about XML namespaces is the indirection: the prefixes can be whatever you want, and then what makes them unique is the URIs they are defined to map to in each document. The one point at which I think it didn't work very well, was when people started using prefixed names in attribute values. You can't tell whether "foo:bar" is a reference to the XML namespace with prefix "foo:", or some unrelated string of "foo:bar", without looking at the schema.
- XorNot 5y agoIn practice though this doesn't really happen: nothing stops someone coming up with the same seemingly unique namespace URI, or using the same namespace prefix. But none of that is really the problem - the problem is that the implementations and parsing are evidently sufficiently difficult that people just don't get them right - hence the hassle. I would argue also that having indirection like this is just a negative all around - having to look elsewhere in the file to figure out what I'm looking at just creates problems, and in practice it doesn't look like this capability was ever really used - the only times I run into it are when I'm dealing with some vendor-specific implementation (that Python or Go or whatever can't handle so string-templating winds up being easier) and it turns out that what I need to have happen is to match the semantics of example XML exactly to get anything to work. Which is really the point: the extra complexity in parsing means the probability you're dealing with a broken parser shoots through the roof, at which point you've lost any advantages. Whereas with JSON, the minimum bar is arrays and maps and the basic types work. Stay within those bounds, and whatever namespacing that happens will "just work".
- skissane 5y ago> nothing stops someone coming up with the same seemingly unique namespace URI If people use URLs, then DNS gives uniqueness to URLs. Of course each registrant has to enforce uniqueness within their registered domain – for a standards organisation or large software vendor, they often adopt a formal system (spreadsheet, database, naming convention, etc) for tracking which parts of the namespace under their domain name are reserved for which products/standards/etc. Of course, that relies on the vendor/organisation to do it properly – but if (e.g.) Microsoft were to create a mess by letting different Microsoft products use conflicting namespace URIs under microsoft.com, well that would be Microsoft's fault, and not the responsibility of any standard or technology to fix it. (There is still one issue–what if the domain changes ownership? Some standards, for example ISO 19770, have tried to address this by constructing namespaces based on a domain name with its registration date, so if the domain later expires and is reused by a different organisation they won't clash since they'll have a new registration date.) > the extra complexity in parsing means the probability you're dealing with a broken parser shoots through the roof A lot of that is because namespaces were added to XML later, rather than being there from the start; they are effectively an optional feature. So then you have some parsers that support them, some parsers that don't, some parsers where it depends on a flag you have to set (which may default to true or false). I guess trying to add namespaces to JSON now would encounter the same problems. But if someone was to design a new serialisation format from scratch, and had namespace support in it from day 1, I don't think these issues would happen.