5 ms·
It doesn't make any sense to look at a situation and say "well, I could save 5 lives at no cost ... but nah". It really doesn't matter who is responsible when a
by roenxi 5y ago
It doesn't make any sense to look at a situation and say "well, I could save 5 lives at no cost ... but nah". It really doesn't matter who is responsible when a self driving car kills someone. We're going to respond by making the self-driving module of the car safer whether it is responsible or not.
We're putting a driver on the road who can still learn after suffering a fatal accident! This is huge, it means all parts of the system can learn from anything and will practically eliminate deaths in the long term; much like in the airline industry. If the short term is safer but confusing we should do that and who cares about philosophical technicalities.
This attitude could literally get people killed for no measurable gain. Saving lives and reducing road deaths (which comes with a whole host of other benefits, like freeing up an enormous number of hours of people's time) is much more important than worrying about holding people responsible. We shouldn't be trying to hold people responsible for tragedies, we should be trying to prevent tragedies!
And we need to keep getting self driving cars into common use to push them up the technological learning curve . This is much more important than worrying about who is at fault because it will make the cars an order of magnitude safer. The payoffs here are so huge it is even worth putting them on the road if they are slightly less safe than humans then subsidising the producer's legal costs to hold their risk down.
- bumby 5y ago>who cares about philosophical technicalities The whole argument above is built upon the assumption that everybody agrees with a utilitarian mindset so I’m assuming the answer to the question, in part, is you should care about the philosophical underpinnings.
- roenxi 5y agoWhich philosophy are people subscribing to where they are happy to accept a mound of corpses in exchange for holding someone accountable? Not preventing them from doing something in the future, mind you. Holding them accountable won't be a net long term improvement. Just accountability for the sake of punishment. I'm sure there are people who believe that, but I suspect most of the reputable philosophers will agree with the utilitarians on this particular issue. It is difficult to defend against "your stubbornness will cause mounds of corpses for no obvious gain". This is a pretty clear cut line of approach.
- simias 5y agoIt's not so much about accountability in the legal sense, it's in the public perception sense. "Old Uncle Bob forgot his glasses again and ran over a kid" doesn't have any implication regarding my use of a car. "A self-driving Tesla was confused by work signage and ran over a kid" would destroy a lot of trust into self-driving cars.
- bumby 5y ago>Which philosophy are people subscribing to where they are happy to accept a mound of corpses in exchange for holding someone accountable? (I'm not a philosopher so maybe somebody with an actual background can correct me if I'm wrong) Ignoring the hyperbole in your statement, I think the traditional counterpoint to consequentialism is deontology. Meaning, the intent behind an action matters despite the consequences. So if you are willingly putting people at risk in the short-term for the "long term good", it's morally wrong. History is rife with examples of how taking an "ends justify the means" philosophy can lead to truly abhorrent policy decisions. >but I suspect most of the reputable philosophers will agree with the utilitarians on this particular issue. This comes across as a "no true Scotsman" defense by implying if one is not a utilitarian in this case, they must not be reputable. Kant is generally considered a "reputable" philosopher and would likely fall on the deontological side of the argument as would many others. >This is a pretty clear cut line of approach. Ethics is not mathematics so there is often no "clear cut" answer. If you are defining policy, absolutism in this realm is dangerous; you have to acknowledge other people's morals may differ from yours and not fall prey to the presumption that just because it makes sense to you, it must be right.
- roenxi 5y ago> Meaning, the intent behind an action matters despite the consequences. So if you are willingly putting people at risk... People by and large don't intend to put people at risk. The intent of someone who causes a car crash is rarely malicious. > This comes across as a "no true Scotsman" defense... I suspect Kant would agree with me that it would be a difficult argument to carry as a philosopher when you are arguing in favour of increasing the corpse count for no particular reason. "If a self-driving car bugs out and kills someone, who's responsible?" certainly isn't a reason to kill people. We can afford to live in ignorance if it means more people live to die in their old age. I'm on board with the idea that maybe someone has a reason that it is a good idea to just let people kill each other by accident. But so far in this thread nobody has bought one up.
- Amezarak 5y agoWhat makes you think cars will ever drive more safely than humans? What if they don’t? This always seems to just be a given, but like GP, I think “self driving safer than humans” requires GAI unless maybe you make massive changes to the road infra.
- manicdee 5y agoThere’s no need for GAI, a driver doesn’t need to solve logic puzzles or crosswords or diagnose medical conditions. A driver needs to identify lanes, understand road markings and signs, model the physics of moving objects and predict the immediate future behaviour of other objects based on immediate past behaviour. Also basing an evaluation of FSD on current AP behaviour is like assuming a housekeeper will be as effective as a Roomba.