4 ms·
Is any remotely "fair" public college admissions system even possible? Race-based quotas are discriminatory. SAT scores are discriminatory. Legacy admissions ar
by paxys 5y ago
Is any remotely "fair" public college admissions system even possible? Race-based quotas are discriminatory. SAT scores are discriminatory. Legacy admissions are discriminatory. Extracurriculars are discriminatory. Judging based on school/school district performance is discriminatory. I say just start picking names out of a hat and be done with it.
- skybrian 5y agoSelecting twice as many candidates as you need and then choosing half of them randomly might actually be a good idea, just so everyone knows that you're there in part because you got lucky. (Also, tracking what happens to each group might result in some interesting data.)
- paxys 5y agoWe can call it the Thanos system.
- ianhawes 5y agoI think a low baseline admissions standard should be required and then any applicants that meet that are selected via lottery.
- nextweek2 5y agoMy first thought was that teaches me to do the bear minimum and then sit back. That doesn't make me feel comfortable. Luck is a factor in life but we want people to work to give them the best chances. Perhaps a lottery where each positive attribute gives a greater chance of winning.
- tolbish 5y agoParents' income?
- delaynomore 5y agoYes, the system that gives my kid the best shot of getting admitted. /s Rich families want legacy admissions. Asian prefer grades and tests because they generally excel in those areas. Under-represented groups want to do away with both because neither legacy or tests benefits them.