6 ms·
That's kind of like if I were morbidly obese, and my diet consisted of 6 big macs, 6 large Cokes and 6 large fries daily, plus a cheesecake at the end of the da
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
That's kind of like if I were morbidly obese, and my diet consisted of 6 big macs, 6 large Cokes and 6 large fries daily, plus a cheesecake at the end of the day for dessert, and I patted myself on the back because I went on a "diet" by cutting out the cheesecake.
Growth in CO2 emissions has recently plateaued, but the world still pumps out about 40% more CO2, every year, than we did in 2000. Stopping the growth doesn't really matter that much, we need to drastically reduce overall emissions.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoIt’s even worse. Not only do we need to get emissions as close to zero as possible, we need to suck a whole bunch of CO2 out of the atmosphere. The amount of effort, resources, energy, and collective action needed is extraordinary. The challenge ahead cannot be overstated. @computerphage: Thank you for the typo correction! I am off for more coffee.
- halsom 5y agoIt simply cannot be done under capitalism.
- ben_w 5y agoSure it can, all you need to do is make it profitable.
- FooHentai 5y agoWhat's interesting is that we already know it's going to result in economic contraction, loss of profits, and general instability in the financial sphere. So we already know that tacking it will be profitable in the long run versus the alternative. Perhaps the conversation needs to center on how to factor the long view into capitalism. Because in my view it is pretty shit at that, with often short term profits favoured over long term and the effects of that being felt long term. Right now our intervention option looks like direct intervention to make things less profitable in the near term, and then we run into the problem of democracy also favouring short-term popularity over long-term stewardship and the immediate pains it bring to voters.
- ethbr0 5y agoIt can most effectively be done under capitalism. Governments need to start paying into a fund, per CO2 ton produced, that pays out, per ton of CO2 removed.
- tejohnso 5y agoIs it capitalism, or is it our current regime? I'm not sure that capitalism itself demands eternal growth, or that pollution not be taken into account. Capitalism doesn't force us to continue to burn fossil fuels. We could impose massive fines or taxes against any greenhouse gas emitter, but we lack social will.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThis. Capitalism doesn't mandate hypergrowth or working yourself to the bone. That's a byproduct of our centralised monetary system and inflation.
- slothtrop 5y agoIt can only be done under Capitalism, since we're at the point where drastically reducing CO2 is woefully insufficient to curb global warming in the next 50-100 years. We need technological innovation to cool the planet.
- notJim 5y agoI'm a socialist, but I hate this meme on the left. We simply do not have time to build socialism before tackling climate change, especially with the recent crushing defeats the left has suffered in Western countries. We have to do this under capitalism, or we will not be able to do it at all.
- throwaway09223 5y agoWell, that and the fact that socialist states universally have worse outcome than capitalist states in this regard.
- gmadsen 5y agoThat isnt the only alternative. A state run free market like china would actually be really useful for this global problem, if of course climate change was the priority for the government. lack of personal freedom and ease of abuse probably make this a terrible choice, but it would without a doubt be better for climate change than currently
- indymike 5y ago> A state run free market like china would actually be really useful for this global problem, if of course climate change was the priority for the government. The cure suggested here is worse than the disease.
- gmadsen 5y agoso my second sentence? And I'm not entirely sure. Is authoritarian rule worse than billions starving to death, with collapse of the ecosystem? All the enlightenment ideas fall apart when we actually reach the limit of the earths resources, and can potentially cause our own extinction along with the rest of the animal kingdom
- ethbr0 5y agoThe balance is between (a) effectively addressing an issue & (b) empowering government and risking it abuse its power. Most long-lived democracies appear to have optimized to mitigate the risk of the second, over the long run, but at the cost of limiting the first. One thinks the Roman Republic had a pretty good thing going politically... but declaring a temporary dictator in times of crisis only worked until it didn't. Still, 475 years was a pretty good run.
- mapmap 5y agoTax the destruction of the commons and the market will react.
- jmcgough 5y agoEvery politician who has attempted or done this has paid a heavy political price. We won't do enough to stop this problem until hundreds of thousands are forced to find new homes, at which point we'll have our hands full with the immediate problems we've caused by this.
- mmcgaha 5y agoIt is not about economic systems, governments, or corporations. People are making choices that do not line up with the bigger things they say they want. Frankly I am getting tired of people with their SUVs, new phones, new computers, plastic everything, and huge homes bitching at me because I am "releasing carbon" when I burn wood. Don't even get me started on the people who bitch about my Nissan versa being gas powered instead of their clean battery powered alternative (Batteries, vehicle electronics, weight, tire size, and the source of their clean energy is my bitch here). People just need to shut the fuck up, live a frugal life and this problem with mitigate itself. The carbon that has been released into the atmosphere from oil is here to stay. I am not even sure we should go looking for some energy guzzling carbon sink because we really need to give the earth time to breath and settle into the ecosystem that exists today. The earth will heal itself and balance will be restored but we can never go back to pre-industrial revolution levels of carbon.
- ethbr0 5y agoAs someone quipped on HN: Reduce. Reuse. Recycle. There's a reason they're suggested in that order.
- oezi 5y agoThe last big expansion of wind and solar from a percentage growth perspective happened when oil was hitting 100 USD. We shouldn't discount how efficient markets are at allocating resources. If expenditures into oil (something like 6bn USD per day) went to wind and solar, then much would change.
- aww_dang 5y agoGovernment subsidies targeted at technologies perceived to be green could potentially be taking resources away from other energy innovations. In the end, some of those innovations might have resulted in greener energy.
- computerphage 5y ago> The challenge ahead cannot be understated. I think you mean "overstated".
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYes! Thank you! Off for more coffee.
- markus_zhang 5y agoYou can't do that right now. Basically what you are asking is to ask a lot of people to lose their jobs, starve, for something uncertain (scientifically proved or not) in the future. In the same time, the only thing we can do, as individuals, is to reduce the emission from our side. But it's wrong to enforce it upon others. Yeah man, downvote me as you wish, but LOL you won't get very far.
- bumby 5y agoI didn’t downvote but would be curious about your definition of “enforcement” that makes it wrong. I assume you mean “morally” wrong here and it seems NOT enforcing repercussions for externalities would be the immoral choice.
- helmholtz 5y agoThis comment is wrong on several levels. First, citation needed for the starvation hyperbole. There are more than a few competent people predicting that tackling climate change will actually create jobs because we will have to solve a whole host of new problems. Things like distribution, mass manufacturing, long term maintenance of equipment, design of the systems in the first place and on and on. Second, "scientifically proved or not"? Are you really questioning whether we've proven climate change is occurring? Finally, if you've been paying attention, you'll notice that the voices telling us that climate change is an individual problem and not a policy reform/regulation problem are basically Big Oil propaganda designed to demoralise you with guilt. It's not about individual action. I would still recommend it for spiritual and philosophical reasons, but not scientific.
- Bishizel 5y agoEffectively this is going to require massive and coordinated action. We are going to have to rapidly develop and share the tech, and scale it quickly. It is also insane how long humanity has ignored this issue. At least we have seemingly moved from ‘12 years left for real action? Hah!’ To ‘Oh shit this is happening and maybe we have that 11 years’
- justsid 5y agoThe good(?) news here is that the ocean is a crazy good CO2 sink. If we were to stop all CO2 emissions, global CO2 levels would start to drop dramatically because the oceans would soak up the atmospheric CO2. This doesn’t work endlessly, but right now about half of the CO2 emissions end up in the oceans, and that system doesn’t just stop if we stop producing it. That being said, it’ll definitely continue to wreak havoc with ocean acidification. But it’s important to know that it’s not necessary to scrub CO2 from the atmosphere to get rid of a huge chunk that has already been emitted.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoMy concern around the ocean as a CO2 sink is how much longer can it absorb CO2 without pH drifting beyond what can support sea life. We keep pulling the elastic band tighter without knowing when it’s going to snap or what happens when it does (metaphorically speaking).
- goose847 5y agoThere’s a book called ‘The Sixth Extinction’ By Pulitzer Prize winner Elizabeth Kolbert which talks about this. The sixth chapter is about the rise in ocean acidity. She also details a critical acidity point (I forget the PH level but I think with current rise in acidity it is modeled to reach that point in 2100) where calcifiers cannot survive due to the acidity essentially breaking down their shells. Think oysters, barnacles, coral. Major parts of the ocean’s ecosystem that could have a ‘cataclysmic’ effect if wiped out.
- sopooneo 5y agoWhen you say "growth has plateaued" do you mean that year on year increases to our output are now constant? Or do you mean year on year output is now roughly constant? I realize this distinction between derivative values is further complicated by the even more baseline measure of total accumulation. But I do ask in earnest and don't know the answer.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoSee https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions. Obviously difficult to determine short/medium-term trends based on the Covid lockdowns.
- adrianN 5y agoThe CO2 concentration on Mauna Loa is publicly available, here's a picture and a script that fetches the data to plot it: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthly_mean_concentration.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mauna_Loa_CO2_monthl... You can compute emission rates from that data yourself.
- gilbetron 5y agoroughly: 2nd derivative of output is now zero (ish), so the 1st derivative is a positive constant. Our CO2 emissions are not accelerating, but still increasing.