8 ms·
The U.S. experience used to be this way, but about 100 years ago the medical industry realized they could make a lot of money off of child birth (our last bill
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
The U.S. experience used to be this way, but about 100 years ago the medical industry realized they could make a lot of money off of child birth (our last bill was $40k).
The hospitals released advertisements scaring women from voodoo (read: black) women/midwives helping with birth so that doctors and surgeons could take over, it worked fantastically. The doctors eventually chained women to beds and tested various chemicals to ‘cure’ their pain that resulted in profound unintended consequences.
This history is still with us, and creates a lot of uncanny valley experiences. I.e. treating pregnancy like a disease.
When we gave birth during covid, I had to use an elevator to get to my wife. When the elevator door opened, a group in hazmat exited with a patient clearly dying of covid.
I was like: “are you fucking kidding me, this is still where we give birth in this country…”
- hallway_monitor 5y agoWe did it in the hospital too but there's nothing stopping you from using a midwife at home right? Another thing that seems to be pushed a lot is epidurals. They expect everyone to get one and are very surprised when someone does not want it.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThen you have to deal with the circumcision sales pitch.
- jjeaff 5y agoWe never heard even the slightest hint of a sales pitch for circumcision. A single question of whether we were planning to do it or not was all.
- Stratoscope 5y agoIn fact, we had an anti-circumcision pitch. They showed a video of the process. It was horrible and makes me queasy just remembering it.
- jjeaff 5y agoIf they were trying to convince you against it, I'm guessing they weren't giving you a video of the average procedure. Kind of like how peta videos aren't exactly representative of how most of the farming industry operates. I watched the one on my son, and while it wasn't nothing, it was a tiny amount of skin and it was healed up very nicely before even his umbilical cord had fully dried and fell off.
- Stratoscope 5y agoI should have been more clear in my comment. I don't think they were trying to convince people against it, just that it had that effect on me personally.
- hahahasure 5y agoThe epidural costs $6000. A 10 minute procedure. I saw my wife before and after an Epidural so I could not dispute it's effectiveness. But I generally can't see a reason why we need to spend 12 years in school to learn how various needles and rules of thumbs work. Only the US has such an education burden, and only does the US have such a strong physician cartel to mandate it.. Edit, and even with midwives you will be hitting max out of pocket with 1 night stay.
- jac241 5y agoThe training length for physicians is pretty much the same in all countries. In the US to become an anesthesiologist: 4 years undergrad, 4 years medical school, 4 years residency. Total: 12 years. In the UK to become an anesthesiologist: 6 years medical school, 2-3 years of general postgraduate training, 5 years specialty training. Total 13-14 years. Why did you not look this simple fact up before saying it authoritatively on here? There's more to it than you think, and it's easy to think that it's a simple procedure whenever you don't know what can go wrong, why things can go wrong, and how to fix things if it does go wrong. Also, the doctor isn't why it's expensive. Doctors don't set the prices, hospitals and health insurance companies do.
- hahahasure 5y agoYikes, n=1? How about Germany or India? Why didn't you look up this simple fact? And yes, The American Medical Association has spent 400M dollars to create a monopoly.
- ezekg 5y agoMidwives are the way. My first child's prenatal and birth was < $5k, born at home.
- spockz 5y agoAmazing. In the Netherlands it is free. You get a midwife, hospital and medical staff when required. You get a box of goods for the first days of baby care. We get 4-6 weeks paid leave as a father and 16 as a mother. There is help in the house for about a week to take care of baby and mother and do checkups. The only thing you pay a symbolic amount of money for is some to borrow tools like bath chairs. Probably some pain meds require a contribution but you never pay the whole thing. Children up until 18 are insured on your own insurance policy without additional fees. It must be hell to live in a cold place as the US where everything costs tons of money out of pocket.
- minusf 5y ago> We get 4-6 weeks paid leave as a father this is technically true, but for context: it started in 2021. Before it was 2 paid days and 3 unpaid days _in total_. Also the last 5 weeks are 70% paid (at least for me)
- brnt 5y agoParental leave in the Netherlands, both for women and man, is the lowest in the EU. By a wide margin. So, while we get some things right, leave and the conseqences that implies for the carreer of the mother is not something we can boast about.
- spockz 5y agoIn 2018 we were indeed among the lowest but not the lowest: https://www.capital-ges.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/1.png https://www.capital-ges.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/1.png from https://www.capital-ges.com/maternity-paternity-and-parental-leave-in-europe/ https://www.capital-ges.com/maternity-paternity-and-parental... I am not sure the career consequences are better elsewhere. What makes you say that pregnancy/motherhood has less effect on careers in different countries?
- Fomite 5y agoThere is no "U.S. experience" because of the absolute mess of our healthcare system. There are birthing centers that work very much like the process described above.
- NateEag 5y agoIndeed - I have to give a plug for UPMC Harrisburg in Pennsylvania. My wife gave birth to all three of our kids there, and while it was more institutional than what's described above, they were big on skin-to-skin contact and leaving it to the parents to parent while the nurses and docs took care of medical needs. Staff was uniformly great throughout all of our births.
- minusf 5y agohow much did it cost if you dont mind me asking?
- tweetle_beetle 5y agoOf course no country of the size of the US has a single experience of anything. But in this case, it's about as close as it can be: 98.4% of births are in hospitals, with 0.52% in birthing centres [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK555484/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK555484/
- Accujack 5y ago>but about 100 years ago It wasn't really an issue for the most part until laws were changed in the early 70s - by Nixon. That was when for profit health care took over here.
- Diesel555 5y agoPerson not alive in the 70s here (and not researched it), but curious why our heath care system is so bad. Could you elaborate on your point / give some sources? It seems interesting to me.
- etempleton 5y agoImmediate skin-to-skin contact has reemerged based on data in the United States. Some hospitals made the switch years ago. Immediate skin-to-skin contact and the newborn, unless there is a medical reason to do otherwise, is never removed from the presence of the birth mother. In some cases this requires re-tooling and renovating the birthing wing of hospitals as they were previously optimized for immediate incubation by default. It takes time and money.