3 ms·

The Braille typing is amazing. She interacts so smoothly and quickly with the keyboard. I wonder why she doesn’t use voice input though?

by nojs 5y ago

zozbot234 5y ago
It's surely amazing when you account for the fact that she's poking at a frickin' touchscreen with no visual closed-loop feedback. But as a UX mode it sucks. Why not just pair a physical Bluetooth gamepad with actual buttons?
- throwaway77112 5y ago
  Touchscreens have vibration feedback when clicking buttons etc
  - zozbot234 5y ago
    That doesn't help with picking the right button, though. She's sort of coping with it by hovering her fingers on the intended portions of the screen but the way she's doing it seems highly unergonomic, and a physical device could also be more efficient.
csomar 5y ago
She's writing on that Braille keyboard faster than your average. Voice input is not a quite private method, too.
toast0 5y ago
> She interacts so smoothly and quickly with the keyboard. I wonder why she doesn’t use voice input though? Presumably because interactimg with the keyboard is smooth and quick. A keyboard is also private and works in noisy environments. Some people (including me) would prefer not to speak when avoidable, jusr as some would prefer not to type when avoidable. It may be easier (or higher throughput) to use audio feedback from the computer while providing touch inputs than if both feedback and input are audio. Personally, while I've spent lots of time training typing, the learning curve on speech to text is too high and the apparenr reward too meager for me to go much beyond the bare minimum (I can cancel many accidental summonings of speech interfaces)
- artur_makly 5y ago
  yeah i had the same knee-jerk question. I can see the use-cases here for non-audio. But for the most part it would seem that audio input get to a level of performance that it simply works 99% of the time with little training. I just broke my screen a few days ago, and b/c of the lock-down here (im in a tiny city) everything was closed. So i was forced to use audio inputs as much as possible, and on the IOS i was horrified that i couldnt simply say "Siri, close this modal" or "Siri, send new whatsapp text to Jane"... shocked.

The Braille typing is amazing. She interacts so smoothly and quickly with the keyboard. I wonder why she doesn’t use voice input though?

by nojs 5y ago

The Braille typing is amazing. She interacts so smoothly and quickly with the keyboard. I wonder why she doesn’t use voice input though?

zozbot234 5y ago

It's surely amazing when you account for the fact that she's poking at a frickin' touchscreen with no visual closed-loop feedback. But as a UX mode it sucks. Why not just pair a physical Bluetooth gamepad with actual buttons?

throwaway77112 5y ago
Touchscreens have vibration feedback when clicking buttons etc
- zozbot234 5y ago
  That doesn't help with picking the right button, though. She's sort of coping with it by hovering her fingers on the intended portions of the screen but the way she's doing it seems highly unergonomic, and a physical device could also be more efficient.

csomar 5y ago

She's writing on that Braille keyboard faster than your average. Voice input is not a quite private method, too.

toast0 5y ago

> She interacts so smoothly and quickly with the keyboard. I wonder why she doesn’t use voice input though? Presumably because interactimg with the keyboard is smooth and quick. A keyboard is also private and works in noisy environments. Some people (including me) would prefer not to speak when avoidable, jusr as some would prefer not to type when avoidable. It may be easier (or higher throughput) to use audio feedback from the computer while providing touch inputs than if both feedback and input are audio. Personally, while I've spent lots of time training typing, the learning curve on speech to text is too high and the apparenr reward too meager for me to go much beyond the bare minimum (I can cancel many accidental summonings of speech interfaces)

artur_makly 5y ago
yeah i had the same knee-jerk question. I can see the use-cases here for non-audio. But for the most part it would seem that audio input get to a level of performance that it simply works 99% of the time with little training. I just broke my screen a few days ago, and b/c of the lock-down here (im in a tiny city) everything was closed. So i was forced to use audio inputs as much as possible, and on the IOS i was horrified that i couldnt simply say "Siri, close this modal" or "Siri, send new whatsapp text to Jane"... shocked.